France | Arbitration clauses in international contracts with consumers are not enforceable

16 Febbraio 2021

  • Francia
  • Arbitrato
  • Contratti
  • Contenzioso

Summary

Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

Price increase in a business relationship

The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

  • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
  • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
  • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

Price increase in a framework contract

If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

  • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
  • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
  • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

  • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
  • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
  • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

  • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
  • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
  • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

Key takeaways:

  • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
  • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
  • document the causes of the price increase;
  • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
  • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

Riassunto

Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

Introduzione

Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

Campo di applicazione

La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

Requisiti contrattuali

L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

Attività suggerite

Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

  • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
  • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

Grafico - Legalmondo

Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

In questo video riassumo:

  • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
  • Cos’è la forza maggiore
  • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
  • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
  • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
  • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
  • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

Le conclusioni sono:

  • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
  • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
  • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

Summary

At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

Is the compensation fair?

Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

Will the agent lose commissions?

Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

 To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

Summary

The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

What happened?

The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

So where do we look for law on those matters?

We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

Where are we now?

If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

  • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
  • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
  • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

The Norwegian exception

The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

How should your business act now?

The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

Novel technology in proceedings

Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

  • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
  • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
  • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
  • the matter concerns an international dispute.

The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

“All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

  • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
  • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
  • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
  • the disclosure of confidential documents
  • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
  • the manner of taking witness testimony
  • the costs of the proceedings.

Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

  • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
  • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
  • The defendant submits its defence statement.
  • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
  • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
  • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
  • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
  • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

Premises to which they are applied

Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

Types of tenants

  • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
  • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

Types of landlords

In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

Measures approved

The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

For landlords different to those mentioned above

The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

Activities to which it is applied

Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

Term to apply and procedure

The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

Alexandre Malan

Aree di attività

  • Arbitrato
  • Distribuzione
  • Assicurazioni
  • Commercio internazionale
  • Contenzioso

Scrivi a Alexandre





    Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
    Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

    Spain | Clientele Compensation for Agents and Distributors

    2 Febbraio 2021

    • Spagna
    • Agenzia
    • Contratti
    • Distribuzione

    Summary

    Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

    Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

    Price increase in a business relationship

    The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

    In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

    A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

    • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
    • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
    • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

    Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

    Price increase in a framework contract

    If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

    In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

    Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

    • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
    • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
    • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

    The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

    • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
    • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
    • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

    The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

    • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
    • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
    • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

    Key takeaways:

    • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
    • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
    • document the causes of the price increase;
    • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
    • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

    Riassunto

    Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

    Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

    Introduzione

    Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

    Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

    Campo di applicazione

    La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

    Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

    La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

    Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

    La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

    Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

    Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

    Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

    Requisiti contrattuali

    L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

    I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

    I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

    Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

    È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

    La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

    Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

    Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

    Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

    L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

    La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

    La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

    L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

    Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

    Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

    Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

    Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

    È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

    In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

    La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

    Attività suggerite

    Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

    • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
    • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

    Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

    Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

    Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

    La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

    Grafico - Legalmondo

    Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

    In questo video riassumo:

    • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
    • Cos’è la forza maggiore
    • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
    • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
    • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
    • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
    • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

    Le conclusioni sono:

    • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
    • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
    • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

    Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

    Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

    In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

    The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

    The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

    It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

    The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

    The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

    Summary

    At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

    For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

    These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

    There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

    Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

    The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

    Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

    If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

    Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

    Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

    How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

    Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

    Is the compensation fair?

    Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

    Will the agent lose commissions?

    Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

    What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

    The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

    And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

    If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

    Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

     To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

    Summary

    The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

    Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

    The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

    Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

    If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

    Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

    On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

    Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

    What happened?

    The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

    So where do we look for law on those matters?

    We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

    Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

    The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

    The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

    The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

    While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

    Where are we now?

    If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

    If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

    The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

    • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
    • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
    • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

    There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

    If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

    The Norwegian exception

    The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

    How should your business act now?

    The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

    This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

    This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

    In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

    English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

    The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

    This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

    The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

    The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

    As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

    The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

    Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

    The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

    Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

    Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

    Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

    The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

    Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

    The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

    There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

    The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

    The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

    As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

    Novel technology in proceedings

    Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

    And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

    Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

    Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

    Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

    • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
    • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
    • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
    • the matter concerns an international dispute.

    The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

    “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

    The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

    Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

    We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

    To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

    Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

    Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

    • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
    • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
    • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
    • the disclosure of confidential documents
    • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
    • the manner of taking witness testimony
    • the costs of the proceedings.

    Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

    All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

    The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

    • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
    • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
    • The defendant submits its defence statement.
    • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
    • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
    • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
    • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
    • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

    Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

    As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

    This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

    Premises to which they are applied

    Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

    Types of tenants

    • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
    • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

    Types of landlords

    In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

    Measures approved

    The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

    For landlords different to those mentioned above

    The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

    Activities to which it is applied

    Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

    If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

    Term to apply and procedure

    The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

    As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

    When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

    Ignacio Alonso

    Aree di attività

    • Agenzia
    • Diritto societario
    • Distribuzione
    • Franchising

    Scrivi a Ignacio





      Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
      Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

      Brexit | Jurisdiction and enforcement – What you need to know

      27 Gennaio 2021

      • Inghilterra
      • Contratti
      • Contenzioso

      Summary

      Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

      Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

      Price increase in a business relationship

      The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

      In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

      A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

      • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
      • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
      • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

      Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

      Price increase in a framework contract

      If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

      In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

      Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

      • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
      • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
      • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

      The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

      • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
      • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
      • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

      The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

      • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
      • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
      • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

      Key takeaways:

      • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
      • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
      • document the causes of the price increase;
      • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
      • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

      Riassunto

      Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

      Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

      Introduzione

      Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

      Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

      Campo di applicazione

      La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

      Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

      La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

      Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

      La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

      Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

      Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

      Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

      Requisiti contrattuali

      L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

      I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

      I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

      Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

      È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

      La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

      Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

      Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

      Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

      L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

      La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

      La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

      L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

      Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

      Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

      Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

      Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

      È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

      In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

      La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

      Attività suggerite

      Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

      • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
      • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

      Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

      Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

      Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

      La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

      Grafico - Legalmondo

      Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

      In questo video riassumo:

      • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
      • Cos’è la forza maggiore
      • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
      • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
      • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
      • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
      • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

      Le conclusioni sono:

      • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
      • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
      • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

      Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

      Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

      In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

      The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

      The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

      It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

      The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

      The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

      Summary

      At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

      For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

      These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

      There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

      Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

      The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

      Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

      If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

      Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

      Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

      How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

      Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

      Is the compensation fair?

      Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

      Will the agent lose commissions?

      Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

      What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

      The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

      And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

      If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

      Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

       To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

      Summary

      The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

      Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

      The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

      Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

      If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

      Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

      On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

      Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

      What happened?

      The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

      So where do we look for law on those matters?

      We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

      Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

      The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

      The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

      The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

      While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

      Where are we now?

      If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

      If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

      The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

      • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
      • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
      • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

      There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

      If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

      The Norwegian exception

      The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

      How should your business act now?

      The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

      This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

      This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

      In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

      English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

      The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

      This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

      The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

      The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

      As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

      The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

      Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

      The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

      Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

      Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

      Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

      The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

      Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

      The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

      There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

      The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

      The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

      As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

      Novel technology in proceedings

      Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

      And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

      Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

      Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

      Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

      • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
      • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
      • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
      • the matter concerns an international dispute.

      The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

      “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

      The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

      Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

      We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

      To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

      Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

      Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

      • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
      • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
      • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
      • the disclosure of confidential documents
      • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
      • the manner of taking witness testimony
      • the costs of the proceedings.

      Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

      All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

      The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

      • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
      • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
      • The defendant submits its defence statement.
      • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
      • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
      • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
      • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
      • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

      Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

      As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

      This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

      Premises to which they are applied

      Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

      Types of tenants

      • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
      • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

      Types of landlords

      In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

      Measures approved

      The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

      For landlords different to those mentioned above

      The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

      Activities to which it is applied

      Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

      If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

      Term to apply and procedure

      The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

      As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

      When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

      Richard Samuel

      Aree di attività

      • Arbitrato
      • Recupero credito
      • Contenzioso

      Scrivi a Richard





        Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
        Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

        M&A, Force Majeure and Covid19 according to the Netherlands Commercial Court

        6 Maggio 2020

        • Paesi Bassi
        • Contratti
        • Contenzioso
        • M&A

        Summary

        Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

        Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

        Price increase in a business relationship

        The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

        In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

        A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

        • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
        • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
        • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

        Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

        Price increase in a framework contract

        If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

        In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

        Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

        • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
        • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
        • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

        The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

        • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
        • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
        • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

        The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

        • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
        • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
        • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

        Key takeaways:

        • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
        • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
        • document the causes of the price increase;
        • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
        • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

        Riassunto

        Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

        Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

        Introduzione

        Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

        Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

        Campo di applicazione

        La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

        Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

        La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

        Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

        La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

        Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

        Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

        Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

        Requisiti contrattuali

        L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

        I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

        I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

        Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

        È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

        La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

        Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

        Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

        Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

        L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

        La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

        La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

        L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

        Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

        Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

        Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

        Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

        È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

        In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

        La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

        Attività suggerite

        Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

        • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
        • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

        Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

        Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

        Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

        La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

        Grafico - Legalmondo

        Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

        In questo video riassumo:

        • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
        • Cos’è la forza maggiore
        • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
        • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
        • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
        • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
        • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

        Le conclusioni sono:

        • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
        • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
        • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

        Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

        Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

        In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

        The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

        The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

        It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

        The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

        The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

        Summary

        At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

        For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

        These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

        There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

        Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

        The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

        Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

        If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

        Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

        Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

        How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

        Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

        Is the compensation fair?

        Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

        Will the agent lose commissions?

        Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

        What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

        The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

        And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

        If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

        Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

         To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

        Summary

        The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

        Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

        The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

        Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

        If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

        Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

        On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

        Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

        What happened?

        The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

        So where do we look for law on those matters?

        We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

        Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

        The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

        The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

        The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

        While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

        Where are we now?

        If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

        If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

        The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

        • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
        • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
        • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

        There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

        If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

        The Norwegian exception

        The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

        How should your business act now?

        The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

        This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

        This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

        In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

        English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

        The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

        This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

        The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

        The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

        As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

        The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

        Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

        The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

        Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

        Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

        Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

        The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

        Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

        The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

        There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

        The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

        The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

        As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

        Novel technology in proceedings

        Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

        And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

        Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

        Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

        Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

        • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
        • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
        • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
        • the matter concerns an international dispute.

        The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

        “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

        The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

        Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

        We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

        To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

        Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

        Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

        • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
        • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
        • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
        • the disclosure of confidential documents
        • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
        • the manner of taking witness testimony
        • the costs of the proceedings.

        Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

        All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

        The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

        • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
        • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
        • The defendant submits its defence statement.
        • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
        • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
        • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
        • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
        • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

        Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

        As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

        This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

        Premises to which they are applied

        Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

        Types of tenants

        • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
        • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

        Types of landlords

        In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

        Measures approved

        The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

        For landlords different to those mentioned above

        The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

        Activities to which it is applied

        Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

        If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

        Term to apply and procedure

        The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

        As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

        When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

        Kai Guldemond

        Aree di attività

        • Contratti
        • Diritto societario
        • Commercio internazionale
        • M&A
        • Private Equity

        Scrivi a Kai





          Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
          Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

          Spain | Covid 19 – Measures for payment of the rent for commercial and industrial premises

          18 Aprile 2020

          • Spagna
          • Contratti
          • Real Estate

          Summary

          Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

          Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

          Price increase in a business relationship

          The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

          In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

          A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

          • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
          • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
          • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

          Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

          Price increase in a framework contract

          If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

          In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

          Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

          • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
          • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
          • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

          The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

          • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
          • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
          • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

          The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

          • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
          • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
          • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

          Key takeaways:

          • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
          • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
          • document the causes of the price increase;
          • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
          • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

          Riassunto

          Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

          Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

          Introduzione

          Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

          Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

          Campo di applicazione

          La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

          Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

          La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

          Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

          La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

          Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

          Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

          Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

          Requisiti contrattuali

          L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

          I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

          I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

          Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

          È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

          La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

          Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

          Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

          Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

          L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

          La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

          La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

          L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

          Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

          Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

          Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

          Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

          È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

          In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

          La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

          Attività suggerite

          Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

          • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
          • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

          Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

          Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

          Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

          La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

          Grafico - Legalmondo

          Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

          In questo video riassumo:

          • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
          • Cos’è la forza maggiore
          • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
          • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
          • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
          • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
          • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

          Le conclusioni sono:

          • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
          • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
          • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

          Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

          Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

          In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

          The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

          The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

          It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

          The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

          The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

          Summary

          At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

          For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

          These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

          There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

          Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

          The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

          Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

          If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

          Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

          Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

          How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

          Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

          Is the compensation fair?

          Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

          Will the agent lose commissions?

          Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

          What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

          The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

          And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

          If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

          Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

           To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

          Summary

          The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

          Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

          The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

          Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

          If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

          Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

          On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

          Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

          What happened?

          The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

          So where do we look for law on those matters?

          We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

          Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

          The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

          The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

          The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

          While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

          Where are we now?

          If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

          If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

          The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

          • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
          • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
          • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

          There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

          If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

          The Norwegian exception

          The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

          How should your business act now?

          The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

          This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

          This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

          In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

          English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

          The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

          This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

          The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

          The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

          As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

          The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

          Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

          The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

          Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

          Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

          Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

          The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

          Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

          The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

          There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

          The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

          The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

          As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

          Novel technology in proceedings

          Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

          And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

          Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

          Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

          Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

          • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
          • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
          • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
          • the matter concerns an international dispute.

          The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

          “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

          The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

          Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

          We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

          To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

          Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

          Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

          • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
          • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
          • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
          • the disclosure of confidential documents
          • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
          • the manner of taking witness testimony
          • the costs of the proceedings.

          Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

          All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

          The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

          • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
          • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
          • The defendant submits its defence statement.
          • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
          • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
          • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
          • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
          • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

          Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

          As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

          This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

          Premises to which they are applied

          Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

          Types of tenants

          • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
          • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

          Types of landlords

          In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

          Measures approved

          The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

          For landlords different to those mentioned above

          The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

          Activities to which it is applied

          Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

          If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

          Term to apply and procedure

          The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

          As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

          When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

          Mercedes Clavell

          Aree di attività

          • Franchising
          • Immigrazione
          • Commercio internazionale
          • M&A
          • Real estate

          Scrivi a Mercedes





            Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
            Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

            Mediation and Covid19 – What we can learn

            13 Aprile 2020

            • Spagna
            • Contratti
            • Contenzioso

            Summary

            Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

            Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

            Price increase in a business relationship

            The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

            In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

            A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

            • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
            • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
            • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

            Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

            Price increase in a framework contract

            If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

            In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

            Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

            • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
            • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
            • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

            The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

            • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
            • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
            • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

            The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

            • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
            • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
            • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

            Key takeaways:

            • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
            • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
            • document the causes of the price increase;
            • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
            • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

            Riassunto

            Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

            Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

            Introduzione

            Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

            Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

            Campo di applicazione

            La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

            Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

            La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

            Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

            La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

            Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

            Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

            Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

            Requisiti contrattuali

            L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

            I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

            I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

            Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

            È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

            La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

            Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

            Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

            Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

            L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

            La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

            La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

            L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

            Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

            Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

            Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

            Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

            È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

            In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

            La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

            Attività suggerite

            Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

            • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
            • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

            Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

            Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

            Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

            La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

            Grafico - Legalmondo

            Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

            In questo video riassumo:

            • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
            • Cos’è la forza maggiore
            • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
            • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
            • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
            • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
            • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

            Le conclusioni sono:

            • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
            • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
            • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

            Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

            Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

            In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

            The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

            The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

            It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

            The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

            The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

            Summary

            At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

            For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

            These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

            There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

            Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

            The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

            Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

            If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

            Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

            Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

            How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

            Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

            Is the compensation fair?

            Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

            Will the agent lose commissions?

            Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

            What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

            The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

            And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

            If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

            Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

             To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

            Summary

            The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

            Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

            The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

            Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

            If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

            Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

            On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

            Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

            What happened?

            The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

            So where do we look for law on those matters?

            We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

            Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

            The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

            The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

            The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

            While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

            Where are we now?

            If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

            If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

            The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

            • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
            • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
            • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

            There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

            If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

            The Norwegian exception

            The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

            How should your business act now?

            The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

            This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

            This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

            In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

            English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

            The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

            This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

            The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

            The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

            As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

            The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

            Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

            The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

            Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

            Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

            Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

            The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

            Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

            The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

            There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

            The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

            The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

            As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

            Novel technology in proceedings

            Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

            And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

            Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

            Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

            Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

            • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
            • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
            • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
            • the matter concerns an international dispute.

            The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

            “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

            The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

            Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

            We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

            To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

            Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

            Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

            • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
            • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
            • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
            • the disclosure of confidential documents
            • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
            • the manner of taking witness testimony
            • the costs of the proceedings.

            Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

            All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

            The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

            • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
            • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
            • The defendant submits its defence statement.
            • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
            • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
            • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
            • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
            • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

            Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

            As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

            This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

            Premises to which they are applied

            Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

            Types of tenants

            • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
            • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

            Types of landlords

            In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

            Measures approved

            The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

            For landlords different to those mentioned above

            The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

            Activities to which it is applied

            Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

            If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

            Term to apply and procedure

            The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

            As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

            When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

            Ignacio Alonso

            Aree di attività

            • Agenzia
            • Diritto societario
            • Distribuzione
            • Franchising

            Scrivi a Ignacio





              Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
              Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

              Spain – The effects of COVID-19 on Lease Agreements of Premises and Offices

              2 Aprile 2020

              • Spagna
              • Contratti
              • Real Estate

              Summary

              Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

              Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

              Price increase in a business relationship

              The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

              In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

              A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

              • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
              • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
              • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

              Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

              Price increase in a framework contract

              If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

              In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

              Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

              • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
              • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
              • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

              The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

              • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
              • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
              • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

              The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

              • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
              • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
              • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

              Key takeaways:

              • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
              • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
              • document the causes of the price increase;
              • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
              • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

              Riassunto

              Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

              Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

              Introduzione

              Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

              Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

              Campo di applicazione

              La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

              Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

              La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

              Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

              La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

              Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

              Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

              Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

              Requisiti contrattuali

              L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

              I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

              I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

              Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

              È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

              La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

              Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

              Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

              Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

              L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

              La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

              La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

              L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

              Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

              Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

              Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

              Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

              È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

              In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

              La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

              Attività suggerite

              Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

              • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
              • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

              Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

              Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

              Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

              La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

              Grafico - Legalmondo

              Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

              In questo video riassumo:

              • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
              • Cos’è la forza maggiore
              • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
              • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
              • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
              • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
              • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

              Le conclusioni sono:

              • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
              • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
              • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

              Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

              Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

              In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

              The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

              The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

              It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

              The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

              The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

              Summary

              At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

              For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

              These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

              There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

              Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

              The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

              Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

              If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

              Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

              Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

              How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

              Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

              Is the compensation fair?

              Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

              Will the agent lose commissions?

              Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

              What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

              The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

              And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

              If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

              Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

               To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

              Summary

              The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

              Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

              The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

              Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

              If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

              Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

              On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

              Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

              What happened?

              The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

              So where do we look for law on those matters?

              We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

              Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

              The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

              The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

              The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

              While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

              Where are we now?

              If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

              If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

              The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

              • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
              • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
              • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

              There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

              If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

              The Norwegian exception

              The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

              How should your business act now?

              The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

              This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

              This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

              In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

              English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

              The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

              This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

              The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

              The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

              As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

              The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

              Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

              The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

              Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

              Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

              Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

              The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

              Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

              The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

              There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

              The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

              The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

              As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

              Novel technology in proceedings

              Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

              And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

              Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

              Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

              Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

              • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
              • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
              • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
              • the matter concerns an international dispute.

              The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

              “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

              The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

              Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

              We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

              To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

              Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

              Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

              • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
              • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
              • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
              • the disclosure of confidential documents
              • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
              • the manner of taking witness testimony
              • the costs of the proceedings.

              Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

              All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

              The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

              • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
              • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
              • The defendant submits its defence statement.
              • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
              • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
              • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
              • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
              • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

              Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

              As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

              This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

              Premises to which they are applied

              Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

              Types of tenants

              • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
              • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

              Types of landlords

              In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

              Measures approved

              The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

              For landlords different to those mentioned above

              The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

              Activities to which it is applied

              Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

              If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

              Term to apply and procedure

              The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

              As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

              When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

              Javier Gaspar Álvarez-Novoa

              Aree di attività

              • Arte
              • Contratti
              • Diritto societario
              • Recupero credito
              • Investimenti stranieri

              Scrivi a Javier





                Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
                Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

                Francia – Il recesso improvviso da un contratto internazionale

                13 Marzo 2020

                • Francia
                • Contratti

                Summary

                Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

                Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

                Price increase in a business relationship

                The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

                In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

                A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

                • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
                • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
                • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

                Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

                Price increase in a framework contract

                If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

                In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

                Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

                • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
                • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
                • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

                The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

                • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
                • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
                • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

                The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

                • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
                • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
                • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

                Key takeaways:

                • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
                • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
                • document the causes of the price increase;
                • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
                • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

                Riassunto

                Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

                Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

                Introduzione

                Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

                Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

                Campo di applicazione

                La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

                Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

                La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

                Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

                La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

                Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

                Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

                Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

                Requisiti contrattuali

                L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

                I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

                I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

                Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

                È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

                La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

                Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

                Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

                Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

                L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

                La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

                La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

                L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

                Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

                Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

                Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

                Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

                È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

                In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

                La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

                Attività suggerite

                Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

                • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
                • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

                Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

                Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

                Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

                La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

                Grafico - Legalmondo

                Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

                In questo video riassumo:

                • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
                • Cos’è la forza maggiore
                • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
                • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
                • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
                • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
                • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

                Le conclusioni sono:

                • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
                • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
                • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

                Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

                Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

                In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

                The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

                The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

                It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

                The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

                The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

                Summary

                At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

                For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

                These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

                There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

                Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

                The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

                Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

                If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

                Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

                Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

                How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

                Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

                Is the compensation fair?

                Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

                Will the agent lose commissions?

                Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

                What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

                The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

                And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

                If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

                Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

                 To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

                Summary

                The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

                Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

                The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

                Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

                If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

                Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

                On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

                Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

                What happened?

                The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

                So where do we look for law on those matters?

                We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

                Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

                The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

                The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

                The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

                While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

                Where are we now?

                If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

                If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

                The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

                • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
                • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
                • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

                There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

                If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

                The Norwegian exception

                The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

                How should your business act now?

                The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

                This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

                This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

                In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

                English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

                The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

                This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

                The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

                The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

                As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

                The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

                Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

                The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

                Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

                Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

                Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

                The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

                Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

                The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

                There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

                The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

                The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

                As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

                Novel technology in proceedings

                Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

                And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

                Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

                Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

                Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

                • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
                • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
                • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
                • the matter concerns an international dispute.

                The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

                “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

                The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

                Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

                We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

                To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

                Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

                Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

                • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
                • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
                • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
                • the disclosure of confidential documents
                • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
                • the manner of taking witness testimony
                • the costs of the proceedings.

                Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

                All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

                The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

                • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
                • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
                • The defendant submits its defence statement.
                • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
                • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
                • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
                • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
                • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

                Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

                As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

                This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

                Premises to which they are applied

                Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

                Types of tenants

                • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
                • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

                Types of landlords

                In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

                Measures approved

                The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

                For landlords different to those mentioned above

                The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

                Activities to which it is applied

                Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

                If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

                Term to apply and procedure

                The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

                As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

                When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

                Christophe Hery

                Aree di attività

                • Agenzia
                • Antitrust
                • Arbitrato
                • Distribuzione
                • e-commerce

                Scrivi a Christophe





                  Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
                  Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.

                  Switzerland – Liability for termination of contract negotiations

                  23 Dicembre 2019

                  • Svizzera
                  • Contratti

                  Summary

                  Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.

                  Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.

                  Price increase in a business relationship

                  The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.

                  In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden “partial” termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).

                  A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:

                  • the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
                  • the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a “partial” termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
                  • the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.

                  Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.

                  Price increase in a framework contract

                  If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?

                  In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of “unforeseeability” provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.

                  Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:

                  • an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
                  • a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
                  • the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.

                  The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:

                  • first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
                  • then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
                  • finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.

                  The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:

                  • article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
                  • this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
                  • during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.

                  Key takeaways:

                  • analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
                  • correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
                  • document the causes of the price increase;
                  • check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
                  • consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.

                  Riassunto

                  Con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 l’Italia ha dato attuazione alla Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 in materia di pratiche commerciali sleali nei rapporti tra imprese (B2B) nella filiera agricola e alimentare. Il legislatore italiano ha introdotto regole più stringenti di quelle previste dalla direttiva. Inoltre, ha previsto alcuni requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, ma più restrittivi di quelli del Regolamento. Le nuove disposizioni si applicano qualunque sia la legge applicabile al contratto e qualunque sia il paese dell’acquirente, quindi riguardano anche i rapporti transfrontalieri. Hanno un impatto significativo sui rapporti contrattuali relativi alla filiera dei prodotti alimentari, freschi e trasformati, compreso il vino, e di alcuni prodotti agricoli non alimentari, e richiedono alle imprese dei settori coinvolti di rivedere i propri contratti e le proprie prassi operative nei rapporti con clienti e fornitori.

                  Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022.

                  Introduzione

                  Con la Direttiva (UE) 2019/633 il legislatore dell’Unione ha introdotto una serie dettagliata di pratiche commerciali sleali relative ai rapporti tra imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare, con la finalità di contrastare le pratiche commerciali squilibrate imposte dai contraenti forti. La direttiva è stata recepita in Italia con il D.Lgs. 8 novembre 2021 n. 198 (entrato in vigore il 15 dicembre 2021) che ha introdotto un lungo elenco di previsioni qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali nell’ambito dei rapporti fra le imprese nella filiera agricola e alimentare. L’elenco delle pratiche sleali è più numeroso di quelle previste dalla direttiva UE.

                  Il recepimento della direttiva è stato l’occasione, poi, per introdurre alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione dei beni rientranti nell’ambito di applicazione del decreto. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli previsti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019.

                  Campo di applicazione

                  La normativa si applica alle relazioni commerciali tra acquirenti (compresa la pubblica amministrazione) e fornitori di prodotti agricoli e alimentari e in particolare ai contratti di cessione B2B di tali prodotti.

                  Sono esclusi i contratti in cui è parte un consumatore, le cessioni con contestuale pagamento e consegna del bene e i conferimenti di prodotti a cooperative o a organizzazioni di produttori ai sensi del D.Lgs. 102/2005.

                  La definizione di contratti di cessione è ampia e include, tra l’altro, i contratti di vendita, di somministrazione e di distribuzione.

                  Per prodotti agricoli e alimentari si intendono i beni elencati all’Allegato I del Trattato sul Funzionamento dell’Unione Europea, nonché quelli non previsti in tale allegato ma che possono essere trasformati per uso alimentare a partire da essi. Sono compresi tutti i prodotti della filiera agroalimentare, freschi e trasformati, incluso il vino, oltre ad alcuni prodotti agricoli fuori dalla filiera alimentare, tra cui i mangimi per animali non destinati all’alimentazione umana e i prodotti della floricoltura.

                  La normativa si applica alle cessioni eseguite da fornitori stabiliti in Italia, mentre non ha rilevanza il paese in cui sia stabilito l’acquirente. Si applica qualsiasi sia la legge applicabile al rapporto fra le parti. Perciò la nuova disciplina si applica anche nel caso di rapporti contrattuali internazionali soggetti ad una normativa di altro paese.

                  Nel recepimento della direttiva, il legislatore italiano ha deciso di non tenere in considerazione le “dimensioni delle parti”: mentre la direttiva prevede soglie di fatturato e si applica ai rapporti contrattuali in cui l’acquirente ha un fatturato pari o superiore al fornitore, la normativa italiana si applica indipendentemente dal fatturato delle parti.

                  Così come ha fatto l’Italia, è possibile che i singoli Stati membri non si siano limitati a un mero recepimento delle previsioni UE, ma abbiano introdotto ulteriori disposizioni che potrebbero incidere in maniera significativa sulle relazioni commerciali.

                  Per le imprese che operano con l’estero sarà dunque importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei vari paesi membri dell’Unione, soprattutto nel caso di gruppi con un’estesa operatività transfrontaliera, i quali si avvalgono solitamente di modelli contrattuali uniformi.

                  Requisiti contrattuali

                  L’art. 3 del decreto ha introdotto alcuni requisiti obbligatori dei contratti di cessione di prodotti agricoli e alimentari. Questi requisiti, adottati nella cornice dell’art. 168 del Regolamento (CE) 1308/2013, sostituiscono, ampliandoli, quelli stabiliti dall’art. 62 del D.L. 1/2012 e dall’art. 10-quater del D.L. 27/2019 (che sono stati abrogati).

                  I contratti devono essere conformi ai principi di trasparenza, correttezza, proporzionalità e reciproca corrispettività delle prestazioni.

                  I contratti devono avere forma scritta. Sono ammesse forme equipollenti (documenti di trasporto, fatture e ordini di acquisto) solo se tra fornitore e acquirente è stato concluso un accordo quadro contenente gli elementi essenziali dei futuri contratti di cessione.

                  Di grande impatto è l’obbligo che i contratti abbiano una durata di almeno 12 mesi (i contratti di durata inferiore sono automaticamente prolungati alla durata minima). Il legislatore impone alle imprese della filiera (salvo alcune possibilità di deroga) di operare non con acquisti singoli ma con contratti di fornitura continuativi, che devono contenere indicazioni circa la quantità e le caratteristiche dei prodotti, il prezzo, la modalità di consegna e di pagamento.

                  È richiesto un notevole cambiamento operativo, per la necessità di programmare e contrattualizzare quantità e prezzi delle forniture. Per quanto riguarda il prezzo, non sembra più possibile concordarlo di volta in volta nel corso del rapporto, sulla base degli ordini o dei nuovi listini del fornitore. Il prezzo può essere fisso o determinabile secondo i criteri stabiliti nel contratto. Perciò le imprese che non vogliano operare a prezzo fisso, dovranno elaborare clausole contrattuali contenenti i criteri di determinazione del prezzo (ad esempio legandolo a quotazioni della borsa merci, a variazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime o dell’energia).

                  La durata minima di almeno 12 mesi può essere contrattualmente derogata. Ma la deroga deve essere motivata, per la stagionalità dei prodotti o per altri motivi che non sono specificati nel decreto. Tra gli altri motivi, potrebbe esservi la necessità per l’acquirente di far fronte a un imprevisto aumento della domanda, oppure la necessità di sostituire una fornitura venuta meno.

                  Le disposizioni sopra descritte possono essere derogate anche da accordi quadro stipulati dalle organizzazioni professionali maggiormente rappresentative.

                  Pratiche commerciali sleali vietate e deroghe specifiche

                  Il decreto prevede diverse fattispecie qualificate come pratiche commerciali sleali, alcune delle quali aggiuntive rispetto a quelle previste dalla direttiva.

                  L’art. 4 prevede due categorie di pratiche vietate, che recepiscono quelle della direttiva.

                  La prima riguarda le pratiche sempre vietate, tra le quali vi è anzitutto il pagamento del prezzo oltre i 30 giorni per i prodotti deperibili e oltre i 60 giorni per i prodotti non deperibili. Vi rientrano poi l’annullamento con scarso preavviso di ordini di prodotti deperibili; le modifiche unilaterali di determinate condizioni contrattuali; le richiesta di pagamenti non connessi alla vendita; le clausole contrattuali che obbligano il fornitore a farsi carico del deperimento o perdita dei prodotti dopo la consegna; il rifiuto di confermare per iscritto le condizioni contrattuali da parte dell’acquirente; l’acquisizione, utilizzazione e divulgazione di segreti commerciali del fornitore; la minaccia di ritorsioni commerciali da parte dell’acquirente verso il fornitore che intende esercitare diritti contrattualmente previsti e la richiesta di risarcimento dell’acquirente dei costi sostenuti per esaminare i reclami dei clienti relativi alla vendita di prodotti del fornitore.

                  La seconda categoria riguarda pratiche che sono vietate salvo siano previste in un accordo scritto fra le parti: in essa vi rientrano la restituzione dei prodotti invenduti senza corrispondere alcun pagamento per essi o per il loro smaltimento; le richieste al fornitore di pagamenti per immagazzinare, esporre, inserire nelle liste o per la messa in commercio dei prodotti; le richieste al fornitore di farsi carico dei costi relativi agli sconti, alla pubblicità, al marketing e al personale dell’acquirente incaricato di organizzare gli spazi destinati alla vendita dei prodotti.

                  L’art. 5 prevede ulteriori fattispecie sempre vietate, aggiuntive rispetto a quelle della direttiva, quali il ricorso a gare ed aste a doppio ribasso; l’imposizione di condizioni contrattuali eccessivamente onerose per il fornitore; l’omissione nel contratto degli elementi indicati nell’art. 168, par. 4 del Regolamento (UE) n. 1308/2013 (tra i quali prezzo, quantità, qualità, durata del contratto); l’imposizione diretta o indiretta di condizioni contrattuali ingiustificatamente gravose per una delle parti; l’applicazione di condizioni diverse per prestazioni equivalenti; l’imposizione di prestazioni o servizi accessorie non connessi alla vendita dei prodotti; l’esclusione degli interessi moratori a danno del creditore o delle spese di recupero dei crediti; le clausole che impongono al fornitore un termine minimo dopo la consegna per poter emettere la fattura; l’imposizione del trasferimento ingiustificato del rischio economico su una delle parti; l’imposizione da parte del fornitore di prodotti con data di scadenza troppo brevi, del mantenimento di un determinato assortimento di prodotti, di inserimento di prodotti nuovi nell’assortimento e di posizioni privilegiate di determinati prodotti nei locali dell’acquirente.

                  Una disciplina specifica è prevista per la vendita sottocosto: l’art. 7 stabilisce che, per quanto riguarda i prodotti freschi e deperibili, questa pratica sia consentita solamente nei casi di prodotti invenduti a rischio deperibilità o nel caso di operazioni commerciali programmate e concordate con il fornitore in forma scritta, mentre in caso di violazione di tale previsione il prezzo stabilito dalle parti è sostituito di diritto.

                  Sistema sanzionatorio e autorità di vigilanza

                  Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto, sia per quanto riguarda i requisiti contrattuali che le pratiche sleali, sono assistite da un articolato sistema sanzionatorio.

                  Sono nulle le clausole contrattuali o pattuizioni contrarie ai requisiti contrattuali obbligatori, quelle che integrano pratiche commerciali sleali e quelle contrarie alla disciplina delle vendite sottocosto.

                  È prevista una sanzione pecuniaria, specifica per ogni fattispecie, che viene determinata fra un minimo fisso (che, a seconda dei casi, può essere da 1.000 fino a 30.000 euro) ed un massimo variabile legato (tra il 3 ed il 5% al fatturato del trasgressore); si prevedono poi determinati casi nei quali la sanzione è ulteriormente aumentata.

                  In ogni caso sono fatte salve le azioni per il risarcimento del danno.

                  La vigilanza sul rispetto delle disposizioni previste dal decreto è rimessa all’Ispettorato centrale della tutela della qualità e della repressione frodi dei prodotti agroalimentari (ICQRF), il quale può condurre indagini, eseguire ispezioni in loco senza preavviso, accertare le violazioni, imporre all’autore di porre fine alle pratiche vietate e avviare il procedimento per l’irrogazione delle sanzioni amministrative pecuniarie, fermo restando le competenze dell’Autorità garante della concorrenza e del mercato (AGCM).

                  Attività suggerite

                  Le previsioni introdotte dal decreto trovano applicazione anche ai contratti in corso, che dovranno essere resi conformi entro il 15 giugno 2022, dunque:

                  • le imprese interessate, italiane ed estere, dovrebbero svolgere una ricognizione delle proprie prassi commerciali, dei contratti in corso e delle condizioni generali di fornitura e acquisto, per poi individuare gli eventuali gap rispetto alle nuove previsioni ed adottare i relativi correttivi.
                  • considerando poi che la nuova normativa è di applicazione necessaria ed è di derivazione UE, per le imprese che fanno affari con l’estero sarà importante comprendere come sia stata data attuazione alla direttiva UE nei paesi in cui operano e verificare la conformità dei contratti anche a tali norme.

                  Una problematica di sempre maggiore impatto sul commercio internazionale post-Covid 19 è la gestione dei prezzi delle materie prime, che spesso l’impresa italiana si trova ad affrontare senza avere espressamente previsto la regolamentazione di questo elemento in un contratto scritto con il proprio fornitore.

                  Si genera così una situazione di incertezza, che è molto pericolosa.

                  Spesso accade che, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo molto forte, si invochi la forza maggiore per sostenere di non essere in grado di adempiere al contratto, ma ciò è sbagliato perché si tratta di due situazioni molto diverse tra loro e vi è il rischio che il rifiuto di adempiere possa essere fonte di responsabilità contrattuale.

                  La situazione è ancor più delicata se, a fronte di una richiesta di aumento del prezzo da parte del proprio forniture straniero, l’impresa è vincolata da un accordo di vendita con prezzo fisso verso i propri clienti, e quindi non può scaricare sull’anello successivo della catena di fornitura l’aumento del prezzo praticato dai fornitori.

                  Grafico - Legalmondo

                  Per gestire le fluttuazioni dei prezzi di materie prime ed energia in modo consapevole è necessario avere le idee chiare e porre in essere comportamenti corretti, iniziando dalla verifica se i contratti  (con fornitori e clienti) prevedono una clausola di Hardship, ossia un meccanismo che prevede quando una parte si trova in una situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e quali sono le conseguenze sul contratto (diritto di rinegoziare il prezzo, di risolvere l’accordo o di nominare un terzo arbitratore che determini il nuovo prezzo della prestazione).

                  In questo video riassumo:

                  • Che cosa è l’eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta (Hardship)
                  • Cos’è la forza maggiore
                  • Quali sono gli effetti delle fluttuazioni delle materie prime sui contratti internazionali
                  • Quali regole si applicano ad un contratto di vendita internazionale
                  • Cosa prevede la legge italiana in materia di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta
                  • Cosa prevede la Convenzione di Vienna del 1980 sulla vendita internazionale di beni mobili
                  • Come regolare le fluttuazioni dei prezzi in un contratto

                  Le conclusioni sono:

                  • La forte oscillazione del prezzo di materie prime ed energia non rende la prestazione impossibile, quindi non può essere invocata come causa di Forza Maggiore e non esonera da responsabilità contrattuale
                  • I forti rialzi dei prezzi possono rappresentare una causa di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta solo se dovuti ad eventi straordinari ed imprevedibili, tra i quali è difficile far rientrare le fluttuazioni, anche molto ampie, delle materie prime
                  • Il rimedio per neutralizzare il rischio di forti fluttuazioni dei prezzi è quello di prevedere nel contratto una clausola di hardship, ossia stabilire quando una parte può notificare all’altra di trovarsi in situazione di eccessiva onerosità sopravvenuta e azionare i meccanismi per riequilibrare le prestazioni oppure terminare l’accordo

                  Legalmondo ha realizzato un Helpdesk online per dare risposta ai quesiti delle imprese e consentire di avere un riscontro rapido e professionale alle esigenze legate alle fluttuazioni dei prezzi delle materie prime sui mercati internazionali.

                  Clicca qui sotto e segnalaci la tua esigenza

                  In an important and very reasoned judgment delivered by the Court of Cassation of France on September 30, 2020, relating to the enforceability of arbitration clauses in international consumer contracts, the Supreme Court judged that these clauses must be considered unfair and cannot be opposed to consumers.  

                  The Supreme Court traditionally insisted on the priority given to the arbitrator to decide on his own jurisdiction, laid down in Article 1448 of the Code of Civil Procedure (principle known as “competence-competence”, Jaguar, Civ. 1re, May 21, 1997, nos. 95-11.429 and 95-11.427). 

                  The ECJ expressed its hostility towards such clauses when they are opposed to consumers. In Mostaza Claro (C-168/05), it referred to the internal laws of member states, while considering that the procedural modalities offered by states should not “make it impossible in practice or excessively difficult to exercise the rights conferred by public order to consumers (“Directive 93/13, concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts, must be interpreted as meaning that a national court seized of an action for annulment of an arbitration award must determine whether the arbitration agreement is void and annul that award where that agreement contains an unfair term, even though the consumer has not pleaded that invalidity in the course of the arbitration proceedings, but only in that of the action for annulment”).  

                  It therefore referred to the national judge the right to implement its legislation on unfair terms, and therefore to decide, on a case-by-case basis, whether the arbitration clause should be considered unfair. This is what the Court of Cassation decided, ruling out the case-by-case method, and considering that in any event such a clause must be excluded in relations with consumers.  

                  The Court of Cassation adopted the same solution in international employment contracts, where it traditionally considers that arbitration clauses contained in international employment contracts are enforceable against employee (Soc. 16 Feb. 1999, n ° 96-40.643). 

                  The Supreme Court, although traditionally very favourable to arbitration, gradually builds up a set of specific exceptions to ensure the protection of the “weak” party.

                  Summary

                  At the end of the agency and distribution contracts, the main source of conflict is the goodwill (clientele) compensation. The Spanish Law of the Agency Contract —like the Directive on Commercial Agents— provides that when the contract is terminated, the agent will be entitled, if certain conditions are met, to compensation. In Spain, by analogy (although with qualifications and nuances), this compensation can also be claimed in distribution contracts. 

                  For the Clientele compensation to be recognized, it is necessary that the agent (or the distributor: see this post to know more) have contributed new clients or significantly increased operations with pre-existing ones, that their activity can continue to produce substantial benefits to the principal and that it is equitable. All this will condition the recognition of the right to compensation and its amount. 

                  These expressions (new customers, significant increase, can produce, substantial advantages, equitable) are difficult to define beforehand, so, to be successful, it is recommended that claims in courts are supported, case by case, on expert reports, supervised by a lawyer. 

                  There is, at least in Spain, a tendency to directly claim the maximum that the norm provides (one year of remuneration calculated as the average of the previous five) without going into further analysis. But if this is done, there is a risk that a judge will reject the petition as unfounded.  

                  Therefore, and based on our experience, I find it convenient to provide guidance on how to better substantiate the claim for this compensation and its amount. 

                  The agent / distributor, the expert and the attorney should consider the following: 

                  Check what the agent’s contribution has been 

                  If there were customers before the contract began and what volume of sales was made with them. To recognize this compensation, it is necessary that the agent has increased the number of clients or operations with pre-existing ones. 

                  Analyse the importance of these clients when it comes to continuing to provide benefits to the principal

                  Their recurrence, their loyalty (to the principal and not to the agent), the migration rate (how many of them will remain with the principal at the conclusion of the contract, or with the agent). Indeed, it will be difficult to speak about “clientele” if there have only been sporadic, occasional, non-recurring customers (or few) or who will continue to remain loyal to the agent and not to the principal. 

                  How does the agent operate at the end of the contract

                  Can he compete with the principal or are there restrictions in the contract? If the agent can continue to serve the same clients, but for a different principal, the compensation could be very much discussed. 

                  Is the compensation fair?

                  Examine how the agent has acted in the past: if he has fulfilled his obligations, his work when introducing the products or opening the market, the possible evolution of such products or services in the future, etc. 

                  Will the agent lose commissions?

                  Here we must examine whether he had exclusivity; his greater or lesser facility to get a new contract (for instance, due to his age, the economic crisis, the type of products, etc.) or with a new source of income, the evolution of sales in recent years (those considered for compensation), etc. 

                  What is the legal maximum that cannot be exceeded?

                  The annual average of the amount received during the contract period (or 5 years if it lasted longer). This will include not just commissions, but any fixed amounts, bonuses, prizes, etc. or margins in the case of distributors. 

                  And, finally, it is convenient to include all the documents analysed in the expert’s report

                  If this is not done and they are only mentioned, it could result in them not being considered by a judge. 

                  Check out the Practical Guide on International Agency Agremeents 

                   To read more about the main features of a contract of agency in Spain, go to our Guide.  

                  Summary

                  The recent post-Brexit trade deal makes no provision for jurisdiction or the enforcement of judgments.

                  Therefore, the UK dropped out of the jurisdiction of the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) on 31 December 2020.

                  The EU has not yet approved the UK’s accession to the Lugano Convention, but may do in the future.

                  Unless the transitional provisions from the Withdrawal Agreement apply, jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments will be governed by the Hague Convention 2005 if there is an applicable exclusive jurisdiction clause

                  If the Hague Convention of 2005 does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules.

                  Judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

                  On the first day of 2021 the UK left the EU regimes with which European lawyers are familiar. We appeared to enter “uncharted territory”. Not so. In fact, there are charts for this territory – or maps, to use a more modern word. You just need to know which maps.

                  Whether you are a lawyer or a businessperson, in whatever country, you need answers to two questions. Which laws govern jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments between EU member states and the UK; and how should businesses act as a result?

                  What happened?

                  The EU and UK reached a post-Brexit trade deal, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (“TCA”), on Christmas Eve 2020. The provisions of the TCA became UK law as the European Union (Future Relationship) Act on 31 December 2020. The TCA made provision for judicial cooperation in criminal matters, but did not mention judicial cooperation in civil matters, or jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial proceedings.

                  So where do we look for law on those matters?

                  We look at the position immediately before Brexit. As every lawyer should know the Brussels (Recast) Regulation (No. 1215/2012) governed the enforcement and recognition of judgments between EU member states.

                  Also, the Lugano Convention 2007 governs jurisdiction and enforcement of judgments in commercial and civil matters between EU member states and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It operates in substantially the same way as Brussels (Recast) does between EU member states.

                  The UK was party to the Convention by virtue of its EU membership. Now that the UK is not a member of the EU, the contracting parties could agree that the UK could join the Lugano Convention as an independent contracting party, and there would be little change to the position on jurisdiction and enforcement. English jurisdiction clauses would continue to be respected and English court judgments would continue to be readily enforceable throughout EU member states and EFTA countries, and vice versa.

                  The problem is that the EU has not agreed to the UK joining the Lugano Convention

                  The UK submitted its application to accede to the Lugano Convention in its own right on 8 April 2020. But accession requires the consent of all contracting parties including the EU. Iceland, Norway and Switzerland have indicated their support for the UK’s accession, but the EU’s position is still not yet clear and the TCA is silent on this matter.

                  While the EU still may belatedly support the UK’s accession to Lugano, it does not currently apply. In any case, a three-month time-lag applies between agreement and entry into force, unless all the contracting parties agree to waive it.

                  Where are we now?

                  If the transitional provisions provided for by the Withdrawal Agreement as explained in my previous post do not apply, the Brussels (Recast) Regulation will not apply to jurisdiction and enforcement between the EU and UK.

                  If they do not, then you first need to decide whether the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements 2005 is applicable. The Hague Convention 2005 applies between EU Member States, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro. The Hague Convention first came into force for the UK when the EU acceded on 1 October 2015 and the UK re-acceded after Brexit in its own right with effect from 1 January 2021.

                  The Hague Convention 2005 applies if:

                  • The dispute falls within the scope of the Convention as provided for by Article 2 – e.g. the Convention does not apply to employment and consumer contracts or claims for personal injury;
                  • There is an exclusive jurisdiction clause within the meaning of Article 3; and
                  • The exclusive jurisdiction clause is entered into after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized, and proceedings are commenced after the Convention came into force for the country whose courts are seized within the meaning of Article 16.

                  There is some uncertainty as to whether EU member states will treat the Hague Convention as having been in force from 1 October 2015, or only from when the UK re-accedes on 1 January 2021. The UK’s view is that the Convention will apply to the UK from 1 October 2015; the EU’s view is that it will apply to the UK from 1 January 2021. What is not in dispute is that for exclusive English jurisdiction clauses agreed on or after 1 January 2021, the contracting states will respect exclusive English jurisdiction clauses and enforce the resulting judgments.

                  If the 2005 Hague Convention does not apply, then the UK and EU courts will apply their own national rules to questions of jurisdiction and enforcement. In the UK, the rules will essentially be the same as the ‘common-law’ rules currently on enforcement applied to non-EU parties, for example the United States.

                  The Norwegian exception

                  The UK and Norway have reached an agreement which extends and updates an old mutual enforcement treaty, the 1961 Convention for the Reciprocal Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil Matters between the UK and Norway, which will apply if the UK does not re-accede to the Lugano Convention. The practical effect of this agreement is that judgments will continue to be reciprocally enforceable between the UK and Norway from 1 January 2021.

                  How should your business act now?

                  The applicable legal framework for each dispute will depend on the facts of each case. You should review the dispute resolution clauses in your cross-border contracts to assess how they may be affected by Brexit and to seek specialist advice where necessary. You should also seek advice on dispute resolution provisions when entering into new cross-border contracts in 2021.

                  This week the Interim Injunction Judge of the Netherlands Commercial Court ruled in summary proceedings, following a video hearing, in a case on a EUR 169 million transaction where the plaintiff argued that the final transaction had been concluded and the defendant should proceed with the deal.

                  This in an – intended – transaction where the letter of intent stipulates that a EUR 30 million break fee is due when no final agreement is signed.

                  In addition to ruling on this question of construction of an agreement under Dutch law, the judge also had to rule on the break fee if no agreement was concluded and whether it should be amended or reduced because of the current Coronavirus / Covid-19 crisis.

                  English Language proceedings in a Dutch state court, the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC)

                  The case is not just interesting because of the way contract formation is construed under Dutch law and application of concepts of force majeure, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of agreements under the concepts of reasonableness and fairness as well as mitigation of contractual penalties, but also interesting because it was ruled on by a judge of the English language chamber of the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC).

                  This new (2019) Dutch state court offers a relatively fast and cost-effective alternative for international commercial litigation, and in particular arbitration, in a neutral jurisdiction with professional judges selected for both their experience in international disputes and their command of English.

                  The dispute regarding the construction of an M&A agreement under Dutch law in an international setting

                  The facts are straightforward. Parties (located in New York, USA and the Netherlands) dispute whether final agreement on the EUR 169 million transaction has been reached but do agree a break fee of €30 million in case of non-signature of the final agreement was agreed. However, in addition to claiming there is no final agreement, the defendant also argues that the break fee – due when there is no final agreement – should be reduced or changed due to the coronavirus crisis.

                  As to contract formation it must be noted that Dutch law allows broad leeway on how to communicate what may or may not be an offer or acceptance. The standard is what a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have understood their communications to mean.  Here, the critical fact is that the defendant did not sign the so-called “Transaction Agreement”. The letter of intent’s binary mechanism (either execute and deliver the paperwork for the Transaction Agreement by the agreed date or pay a EUR 30 million fee) may not have been an absolute requirement for contract formation (under Dutch law) but has significant evidentiary weight. In M&A practice – also under Dutch law – with which these parties are thoroughly familiar with, this sets a very high bar for  concluding a contract was agreed other than by explicit written agreement. So, parties may generally comfortably rely on what they have agreed on in writing with the assistance of their advisors.

                  The communications relied on by claimant in this case did not clear the very high bar to assume that despite the mechanism of the letter of intent and the lack of a signed Transaction Agreement there still was a binding agreement. In particular attributing the other party’s advisers’ statements and/or conduct to the contracting party they represent did not work for the claimant in this case as per the verdict nothing suggested that the advisers would be handling everything, including entering into the agreement.

                  Court order for actual performance of a – deemed – agreement on an M&A deal?

                  The Interim Injunction Judge finds that there is not a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits so as to justify an interim measure ordering the defendant to actually perform its obligations under the disputed Transaction Agreement (payment of EUR 169 million and take the claimant’s 50% stake in an equestrian show-jumping business).

                  Enforcement of the break fee despite “Coronavirus”?

                  Failing the conclusion of an agreement, there was still another question to answer as the letter of intent mechanism re the break fee as such was not disputed. Should the Court enforce the full EUR 30 million fee in the current COVID-19 circumstances? Or should the fee’s effects be modified, mitigated or reduced in some way, or  the fee agreement should even be dissolved?

                  Unforeseen circumstances, reasonableness and fairness

                  The Interim Injunction Judge rules that the coronavirus crisis may be an unforeseen circumstance, but it is not of such a nature that, according to standards of reasonableness and fairness, the plaintiff cannot expect the break fee obligation to remain unchanged. The purpose of the break fee is to encourage parties to enter into the transaction and attribute / share risks between them. As such the fee limits the exposure of the parties. Payment of the fee is a quick way out of the obligation to pay the purchase price of EUR 169 million and the risks of keeping the target company financially afloat. If financially the coronavirus crisis turns out less disastrous than expected, the fee of EUR 30 million may seem high, but that is what the parties already considered reasonable when they waived their right to invoke the unreasonableness of the fee. The claim for payment of the EUR 30 million break fee is therefore upheld by the Interim Injunction Judge.

                  Applicable law and the actual practice of it by the courts

                  The relevant three articles are in this case articles 6:94, 6:248 and 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code. They relate to the mitigation of contractual penalties, unforeseen circumstances and amendment of the agreement under the tenets of reasonableness and fairness. Under Dutch law the courts must with all three exercise caution. Contracts must generally be enforced as agreed. The parties’ autonomy is deemed paramount and the courts’ attitude is deferential. All three articles use language stating, essentially, that interference by the courts in the contract’s operation is allowed only to avoid an “unacceptable” impact, as assessed under standards of reasonableness and fairness.

                  There is at this moment of course no well- established case law on COVID-19. However, commentators have provided guidance that is very helpful to think through the issues. Recently a “share the pain” approach has been advocated by a renowned law Professor, Tjittes, who focuses on preserving the parties’ contractual equilibrium in the current circumstances. This is, in the Court’s analysis, the right way to look at the agreement here. There is no evidence in the record suggesting that the parties contemplated or discussed the full and exceptional impact of the COVID-19 crisis. The crisis may or may not be unprovided for.  However, the court rules in the current case there is no need to rule on this issue. Even if the crisis is unprovided for, there is no support in the record for the proposition that the crisis makes it unacceptable for the claimant to demand strict performance by the defendant. The reasons are straightforward.

                  The break fee allocates risk and expresses commitment and caps exposure. The harm to the business may be substantial and structural, or it may be short-term and minimal. Either way, the best “share the pain” solution, to preserve the contractual equilibrium in the agreement, is for the defendant to pay the fee as written in the letter of intent. This allocates a defined risk to one party, and actual or potential risks to the other party. Reducing the break fee in any business downturn, the fee’s express purpose – comfort and confidence to get the deal done – would not be accomplished and be derived in precisely the circumstances in which it should be robust. As a result, the Court therefore orders to pay the full EUR 30 million fee. So the break fee stipulation works under the circumstances without mitigation because of the Corona outbreak.

                  The Netherlands Commercial Court, continued

                  As already indicated above, the case is interesting because the verdict has been rendered by a Dutch state court in English and the proceedings where also in English. Not because of a special privilege granted in a specific case but based on an agreement between parties with a proper choice of forum clause for this court. In addition to the benefit to of having an English forum without mandatorily relying on either arbitration or choosing an anglophone court, it also has the benefit of it being a state court with the application of the regular Dutch civil procedure law, which is well known by it’s practitioners and reduces the risk of surprises of a procedural nature.  As it is as such also a “normal” state court, there is the right to appeal and particularly effective under Dutch law access to expedited proceeding as was also the case in the example referred to above. This means a regular procedure with full application of all evidentiary rules may still follow, overturning or confirming this preliminary verdict in summary proceedings.

                  Novel technology in proceedings

                  Another first or at least a novel application is that all submissions were made in eNCC, a document upload procedure for the NCC. Where the introduction of electronic communication and litigation in the Dutch court system has failed spectacularly, the innovations are now all following in quick order and quite effective. As a consequence of the Coronavirus outbreak several steps have been quickly tried in practice and thereafter formally set up. At present this – finally – includes a secure email-correspondence system between attorneys and the courts.

                  And, also by special order of the Court in this present case, given the current COVID-19 restrictions the matter was dealt with at a public videoconference hearing on 22 April 2020 and the case was set for judgment on 29 April 2020 and published on 30 April 2020.

                  Even though it is a novel application, it is highly likely that similar arrangements will continue even after expiry of current emergency measures. In several Dutch courts videoconference hearings are applied on a voluntary basis and is expected that the arrangements will be formalized.

                  Eligibility of cases for the Netherlands Commercial Court

                  Of more general interest are the requirements for matters that may be submitted to NCC:

                  • the Amsterdam District Court or Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction
                  • the parties have expressly agreed in writing that proceedings will be in English before the NCC (the ‘NCC agreement’)
                  • the action is a civil or commercial matter within the parties’ autonomy
                  • the matter concerns an international dispute.

                  The NCC agreement can be recorded in a clause, either before or after the dispute arises. The Court even recommends specific wording:

                  “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or “NCC District Court”), to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts. An action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law may be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCCA”).”

                  The phrase “to the exclusion of the jurisdiction of any other courts” is included in light of the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. It is not mandatory to include it of course and parties may decide not to exclude the jurisdiction of other courts or make other arrangements they consider appropriate. The only requirement being that such arrangements comply with the rules of jurisdiction and contract. Please note that choice of court agreements are exclusive unless the parties have “expressly provided” or “agreed” otherwise (as per the Hague Convention and Recast Brussels I Regulation).

                  Parties in a pending case before another Dutch court or chamber may request that their case be referred to NCC District Court or NCC Court of Appeal. One of the requirements is to agree on a clause that takes the case to the NCC and makes English the language of the proceedings. The NCC recommends using this language:

                  We hereby agree that all disputes in connection with the case [name parties], which is currently pending at the *** District Court (case number ***), will be resolved by the Amsterdam District Court following proceedings in English before the Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court” or ”NCC District Court). Any action for interim measures, including protective measures, available under Dutch law will be brought in the NCC’s Court in Summary Proceedings (CSP) in proceedings in English. Any appeals against NCC or CSP judgments will be submitted to the Amsterdam Court of Appeal’s Chamber for International Commercial Matters (“Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal” or “NCC Court of Appeal”).

                  To request a referral, a motion must be made before the other chamber or court where the action is pending, stating the request and contesting jurisdiction (if the case is not in Amsterdam) on the basis of a choice-of-court agreement (see before).

                  Additional arrangements in the proceedings before the Netherlands Commercial Court

                  Before or during the proceedings, parties can also agree special arrangements in a customized NCC clause or in another appropriate manner. Such arrangements may include matters such as the following:

                  • the law applicable to the substantive dispute
                  • the appointment of a court reporter for preparing records of hearings and the costs of preparing those records
                  • an agreement on evidence that departs from the general rules
                  • the disclosure of confidential documents
                  • the submission of a written witness statement prior to the witness examination
                  • the manner of taking witness testimony
                  • the costs of the proceedings.

                  Visiting lawyers and typical course of the procedure

                  All acts of process are in principle carried out by a member of the Dutch Bar. Member of the Bar in an EU or EEA Member State or Switzerland may work in accordance with Article 16e of the Advocates Act (in conjunction with a member of the Dutch Bar). Other visiting lawyers may be allowed to speak at any hearing.

                  The proceedings will typically follow the below steps:

                  • Submitting the initiating document by the plaintiff (summons or request as per Dutch law)
                  • Assigned to three judges and a senior law clerk.
                  • The defendant submits its defence statement.
                  • Case management conference or motion hearing (e.g. also in respect of preliminary issues such as competence, applicable law etc.) where parties may present their arguments.
                  • Judgment on motions: the court rules on the motions. Testimony, expert appointment, either at this stage or earlier or later.
                  • The court may allow the parties to submit further written statements.
                  • Hearing: the court interviews the parties and allows them to present their arguments. The court may enquire whether the dispute could be resolved amicably and, where appropriate, assist the parties in a settlement process. If appropriate, the court may discuss with the parties whether it would be advisable to submit part or all of the dispute to a mediator. At the end of the hearing, the court will discuss with the parties what the next steps should be.
                  • Verdict: this may be a final judgment on the claims or an interim judgment ordering one or more parties to produce evidence, allowing the parties to submit written submissions on certain aspects of the case, appointing one or more experts or taking other steps.

                  Continuous updates, online resources Netherlands Commercial Court

                  As a final note the English language website of the Netherlands Commercial Court provides ample information on procedure and practical issues and is updated with a high frequence. Under current circumstance even at a higher pace. In particular for practitioners it’s recommended to regularly consult the website. https://www.rechtspraak.nl/English/NCC/Pages/default.aspx

                  This is a summary of the approved measures, which unfortunately for both tenants and landlords do not include any public aid or tax relief and just refer to a postponement in the payment of the rent.

                  Premises to which they are applied

                  Leased premises dedicated to activities different than residential: commercial, professional, industrial, cultural, teaching, amusement, healthcare, etc. They also apply to the lease of a whole industry (i.e. hotels, restaurants, bars, etc., which are the most usual type of businesses object of this deal).

                  Types of tenants

                  • Individual entrepreneurs or self-employed persons who were registered before Social Security before the declaration of the state of alarm on March 14th, 2020
                  • Small and medium companies, as defined by article 257.1 of the Capital Companies Act: those who fulfil during two consecutive fiscal years these figures: assets under € 4 million, turnover under € 8 million and average staff under 50 people

                  Types of landlords

                  In order to benefit from these measures, the landlord should be a housing public entity or company or a big owner, considering as such the individuals or companies who own more than 10 urban properties (excluding parking places and storage rooms) or a built surface over 1.500 sqm.

                  Measures approved

                  The payment of the rent is postponed without interest meanwhile the state of alarm is in force, but in any case, for a maximum period of four months. Once the state of alarm is overcome, and in any case in a maximum term of four months, the postponed rents should be paid along a maximum period of two years, or the duration of the lease agreement, should it be less than two years.

                  For landlords different to those mentioned above

                  The tenant could apply before the landlord for the postponement in the payment of the rent (but the landlord is not obliged to accept it), and the parties can use the guarantee that the tenant should mandatorily have provided at the beginning of any lease agreement (usually equal to two month’s rent, but could be more if agreed by the parties), in full or in part, in order to use it to pay the rent. The tenant will have to provide again the guarantee within one year’s term, or less should the lease agreement have a shorter duration.

                  Activities to which it is applied

                  Activities which have been suspended according to the Royal Decree that declared the state of alarm, dated march, 14ht, 2020, or according to the orders issued by the authorities delegated by such Royal Decree. This should be proved through a certificated issued by the tax authorities.

                  If the activity has not been directly suspended by the Royal Decree, the turnover during the month prior to the postponement should be less than 75% of the average monthly turnover during the same quarter last year. This should be proved through a responsible declaration by the tenant, and the landlord is authorised check the bookkeeping records.

                  Term to apply and procedure

                  The tenant should apply for these measures before the landlord within one month’s term from the publication of the Royal Decree-law, that is, from April 22nd, 2020, and the landlord (in case belongs to the groups mentioned in point c) is obliged to accept the tenant’s request, except if both parties have already agreed something different. The postponement would be applied to the following month.

                  As the state of alarm was declared more than one month ago (March 14th), landlords and tenants have already been reaching some agreements, for example 50% rent reduction during the state of alarm, and 50% rent postponement during the following 6 months. Tenants who do not reach an agreement with the landlord could face an eviction procedure, however court procedures are suspended during the state of alarm. We have also seen some abusive non-payment of rent by tenants.

                  When is becomes impossible to reach an agreement with the landlord, tenants have the legal remedy of claiming in Court for the application of the “rebus sic stantibus” principle, which was highly demanded during the 2008 financial crisis but very seldom applied by the Courts. This principle is aimed to re-balance the parties’ obligations when their situation had deeply changed because of unforeseen circumstances beyond their control. This principle is not included in the Spanish Civil Code, but the Supreme Court has accepted its application, in a very restricted way, in some occasions.

                  Renato Bucher

                  Aree di attività

                  • Agenzia
                  • Antitrust
                  • Contratti
                  • Distribuzione
                  • Franchising

                  Scrivi a Renato





                    Leggi la privacy policy di Legalmondo.
                    Questo sito è protetto da reCAPTCHA e si applicano le Norme sulla privacy e i Termini di servizio di Google.