-
Francia
France: Review and renegotiation of price in case of costs increase
5 de mayo de 2022
- Contratos
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Christophe
The Distribution of wine in Mexico
7 de marzo de 2021
-
Mexico
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Joaquin
España | La indemnización por clientela para Agentes y Distribuidores
2 de febrero de 2021
-
España
- Agencia
- Contratos
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Ignacio
France: control by the supplier of online resales by its distributors
31 de diciembre de 2020
-
Francia
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Christophe
Cobro internacional de deudas: evitar riesgos y la mejor forma de actuar
7 de diciembre de 2020
-
España
- Contratos de distribución
- Litigios
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Ignacio
RCEP – The largest Free Trade Agreement
19 de noviembre de 2020
-
Singapur
-
Vietnam
- Contratos de distribución
- Inversiones
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Federico
France – Terms of payment in an international agreement
2 de noviembre de 2020
-
Francia
- Derecho Societario
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Christophe
China – Internet Frauds and online Scams
25 de agosto de 2020
-
China
- Contratos de distribución
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.
Contacta con Roberto
P2B Regulation – How to adapt Platform services and Search Engines
2 de agosto de 2020
-
Europa
- Mediación
- Contratos de distribución
- e-commerce
Summary
On 1 June 2022, Regulation EU n. 720/2022, i.e.: the new Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (hereinafter: «VBER»), replaced the previous version (Regulation EU n. 330/2010), expired on 31 May 2022.
The new VBER and the new vertical guidelines (hereinafter: “Guidelines”) have received the main evidence gathered during the lifetime of the previous VBER and contain some relevant provisions affecting the discipline of all B2B agreements among businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain.
In this article, we will focus on the impact of the new VBER on sales through digital platforms, listing the main novelties impacting distribution chains, including a platform for marketing products/services.
The general discipline of vertical agreements
Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) prohibits all agreements that prevent, restrict, or distort competition within the EU market, listing the main types, e.g.: price fixing; market partitioning; limitations on production/development/investment; unfair terms, etc.
However, Article 101(3) TFEU exempts from such restrictions the agreements that contribute to improving the EU market, to be identified in a special category Regulation.
The VBER establishes the category of vertical agreements (i.e., agreements between businesses operating at different levels of the supply chain), determining which of these agreements are exempted from Article 101(1) TFEU prohibition.
In short, vertical agreements are presumed to be exempted (and therefore valid) if they do not contain so-called «hardcore restrictions» (i.e., severe restrictions of competition, such as an absolute ban on sales in a territory or the manufacturer’s determination of the distributor’s resale price) and if neither party’s market share exceeds 30%.
The exempted agreements benefit from what has been termed the “safe harbour” of the VBER. In contrast, the others will be subject to the general prohibition of Article 101(1) TFEU unless they can benefit from an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The innovations introduced by the new VBER to online platforms
The first relevant aspect concerns the classification of the platforms, as the European Commission excluded that the online platform generally meets the conditions to be categorized as agency agreements.
While there have never been doubts concerning platforms that operate by purchasing and reselling products (classic example: Amazon Retail), some have arisen concerning those platforms that merely promote the products of third parties without carrying out the activity of resale (classic example: Amazon Marketplace).
With this statement, the European Commission wanted to clear the field of doubt, making explicit that intermediation service providers (such as online platforms) qualify as suppliers (as opposed to commercial agents) under the VBER. This reflects the approach of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 («P2B Regulation»), which has, for the first time, dictated a specific discipline for digital platforms. It provided for a set of rules to create a “fair, transparent, and predictable environment” for smaller businesses and customers” and for the rationale of the Digital Markets Act, banning certain practices used by large platforms acting as “gatekeepers”.
Therefore, all contracts concluded between manufacturers and platforms (defined as ‘providers of online intermediation services’) are subject to all the restrictions imposed by the VBER. These include the price, the territories to which or the customers to whom the intermediated goods or services may be sold, or the restrictions relating to online advertising and selling.
Thus, to give an example, the operator of a platform may not impose a fixed or minimum sale price for a transaction promoted through the platform.
The second most impactful aspect concerns hybrid platforms, i.e., competing in the relevant market to sell intermediated goods or services. Amazon is the most well-known example, as it is a provider of intermediation services (“Amazon Marketplace”), and – at the same time – it distributes the products of those parties (“Amazon Retail”). We have previously explored the distinction between those 2 business models (and the consequences in terms of intellectual property infringement) here.
The new VBER explicitly does not apply to hybrid platforms. Therefore, the agreements concluded among such platforms and manufacturers are subject to the limitations of the TFEU, as such providers may have the incentive to favour their sales and the ability to influence the outcome of competition between undertakings that use their online intermediation services.
Those agreements must be assessed individually under Article 101 of the TFEU, as they do not necessarily restrict competition within the meaning of TFEU, or they may fulfil the conditions of an individual exemption under Article 101(3) TFUE.
The third very relevant aspect concerns the parity obligations (also referred to as Most Favoured Nation Clauses, or MFNs), i.e., the contract provisions in which a seller (directly or indirectly) agrees to give the buyer the best terms it makes available to any other buyer.
Indeed, platforms’ contractual terms often contain parity obligation clauses to prevent users from offering their products/services at lower prices or on better conditions on their websites or other platforms.
The new VBER deals explicitly with parity clauses, making a distinction between clauses whose purpose is to prohibit users of a platform from selling goods or services on more favourable terms through competing platforms (so-called “wide parity clauses”), and clauses that prohibit sales on more favourable terms only in respect of channels operated directly by the users (so-called “narrow parity clauses”).
Wide parity clauses do not benefit from the VBER exemption; therefore, such obligations must be assessed individually under Article 101(3) TFEU.
On the other hand, narrow parity clauses continue to benefit from the exemption already granted by the old VBER if they do not exceed the threshold of 30% of the relevant market share set out in Article 3 of the new VBER. However, the new Guidelines warn against using overly narrow parity obligations by online platforms covering a significant share of users, stating that if there is no evidence of pro-competitive effects, the benefit of the block exemption is likely to be withdrawn.
Impact and takeaways
The new VBER entered into force on 1 June 2022 and is already applicable to agreements signed after that date. Agreements already in force on 31 May 2022 that satisfy the conditions for exemption under the current VBER but do not satisfy the requirements under the new VBER shall benefit from a one-year transitional period.
The new regime will be the playing field for all platform-driven sales over the next 12 years (the regulation expires on 31 May 2034). Currently, the rather restrictive novelties on hybrid platforms and parity obligations will likely necessitate substantial revisions to existing trade agreements.
Here, then, are some tips for managing contracts and relationships with online platforms:
- the new VBER is the right opportunity to review the existing distribution networks. The revision will have to consider not only the new regulatory limits (e.g., the ban on wide parity clauses) but also the new discipline reserved for hybrid platforms and dual distribution to coordinate the different distribution channels as efficiently as possible, by the stakes set by the new VBER and the Guidelines;
- platforms are likely to play an even greater role during the next decade; it is, therefore, essential to consider these sales channels from the outset, coordinating them with the other existing ones (retail, direct sales, distributors, etc.) to avoid jeopardizing the marketing of products or services;
- the European legislator’s attention toward platforms is growing. Looking up from the VBER, one should not forget that they are subject to a multitude of other European regulations, which are gradually regulating the sector and which must be considered when concluding contracts with platforms. The reference is not only to the recent Digital Market Act and P2B Regulation but also to the protection of IP rights on platforms, which – as we have already seen – is still an open issue.
Summary
To avoid disputes with important suppliers, it is advisable to plan purchases over the medium and long term and not operate solely on the basis of orders and order confirmations. Planning makes it possible to agree on the duration of the ‘supply agreement, minimum volumes of products to be delivered and delivery schedules, prices, and the conditions under which prices can be varied over time.
The use of a framework purchase agreement can help avoid future uncertainties and allows various options to be used to manage commodity price fluctuations depending on the type of products , such as automatic price indexing or agreement to renegotiate in the event of commodity fluctuations beyond a certain set tolerance period.
I read in a press release: “These days, the glass industry is sending wine companies new unilateral contract amendments with price changes of 20%…”
What can one do to avoid the imposition of price increases by suppliers?
- Know your rights and act in an informed manner
- Plan and organise your supply chain
Does my supplier have the right to increase prices?
If contracts have already been concluded, e.g., orders have already been confirmed by the supplier, the answer is often no.
It is not legitimate to request a price change. It is much less legitimate to communicate it unilaterally, with the threat of cancelling the order or not delivering the goods if the request is not granted.
What if he tells me it is force majeure?
That’s wrong: increased costs are not a force majeure but rather an unforeseen excessive onerousness, which hardly happens.
What if the supplier canceled the order, unilaterally increased the price, or did not deliver the goods?
He would be in breach of contract and liable to pay damages for violating his contractual obligations.
How can one avoid a tug-of-war with suppliers?
The tools are there. You have to know them and use them.
It is necessary to plan purchases in the medium term, agreeing with suppliers on a schedule in which are set out:
- the quantities of products to be ordered
- the delivery terms
- the durationof the agreement
- the pricesof the products or raw materials
- the conditions under which prices can be varied
There is a very effective instrument to do so: a framework purchase agreement.
Using a framework purchase agreement, the parties negotiate the above elements, which will be valid for the agreed period.
Once the agreement is concluded, product orders will follow, governed by the framework agreement, without the need to renegotiate the content of individual deliveries each time.
For an in-depth discussion of this contract, see this article.
- “Yes, but my suppliers will never sign it!”
Why not? Ask them to explain the reason.
This type of agreement is in the interest of both parties. It allows planning future orders and grants certainty as to whether, when, and how much the parties can change the price.
In contrast, acting without written agreements forces the parties to operate in an environment of uncertainty. Suppliers can request price increases from one day to the next and refuse supply if the changes are not accepted.
How are price changes for future supplies regulated?
Depending on the type of products or services and the raw materials or energy relevant in determining the final price, there are several possibilities.
- The first option is to index the price automatically. E.g., if the cost of a barrel of Brent oil increases/decreases by 10%, the party concerned is entitled to request a corresponding adjustment of the product’s price in all orders placed as of the following week.
- An alternative is to provide for a price renegotiation in the event of a fluctuation of the reference commodity. E.g., suppose the LME Aluminium index of the London Stock Exchange increases above a certain threshold. In that case, the interested party may request a price renegotiationfor orders in the period following the increase.
What if the parties do not agree on new prices?
It is possible to terminate the contract or refer the price determination to a third party, who would act as arbitrator and set the new prices for future orders.
Summary
The framework supply contract is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier) that take place over a certain period of time. This agreement determines the main elements of future contracts such as price, product volumes, delivery terms, technical or quality specifications, and the duration of the agreement.
The framework contract is useful for ensuring continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a certain product that is essential for planning industrial or commercial activity. While the general terms and conditions of purchase or sale are the rules that apply to all suppliers or customers of the company. The framework contract is advisable to be concluded with essential suppliers for the continuity of business activity, in general or in relation to a particular project.
What I am talking about in this article:
- What is the supply framework agreement?
- What is the function of the supply framework agreement?
- The difference with the general conditions of sale or purchase
- When to enter a purchase framework agreement?
- When is it beneficial to conclude a sales framework agreement?
- The content of the supply framework agreement
- Price revision clause and hardship
- Delivery terms in the supply framework agreement
- The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
- International sales: applicable law and dispute resolution arrangements
What is a framework supply agreement?
It is an agreement that regulates a series of future sales and purchases between two parties (customer and supplier), which will take place over a certain period.
It is therefore referred to as a «framework agreement» because it is an agreement that establishes the rules of a future series of sales and purchase contracts, determining their primary elements (such as the price, the volumes of products to be sold and purchased, the delivery terms of the products, and the duration of the contract).
After concluding the framework agreement, the parties will exchange orders and order confirmations, entering a series of autonomous sales contracts without re-discussing the covenants already defined in the framework agreement.
Depending on one’s point of view, this agreement is also called a sales framework agreement (if the seller/supplier uses it) or a purchasing framework agreement (if the customer proposes it).
What is the function of the framework supply agreement?
It is helpful to arrange a framework agreement in all cases where the parties intend to proceed with a series of purchases/sales of products over time and are interested in giving stability to the commercial agreement by determining its main elements.
In particular, the purchase framework agreement may be helpful to a company that wishes to ensure continuity of supply from one or more suppliers of a specific product that is essential for planning its industrial or commercial activity (raw material, semi-finished product, component).
By concluding the framework agreement, the company can obtain, for example, a commitment from the supplier to supply a particular minimum volume of products, at a specific price, with agreed terms and technical specifications, for a certain period.
This agreement is also beneficial, at the same time, to the seller/supplier, which can plan sales for that period and organize, in turn, the supply chain that enables it to procure the raw materials and components necessary to produce the products.
What is the difference between a purchase or sales framework agreement and the general terms and conditions?
Whereas the framework agreement is an agreement that is used with one or more suppliers for a specific product and a certain time frame, determining the essential elements of future contracts, the general purchase (or sales) conditions are the rules that apply to all the company’s suppliers (or customers).
The first agreement, therefore, is negotiated and defined on a case-by-case basis. At the same time, the general conditions are prepared unilaterally by the company, and the customers or suppliers (depending on whether they are sales or purchase conditions) adhere to and accept that the general conditions apply to the individual order and/or future contracts.
The two agreements might also co-exist: in that case; it is a good idea to specify which contract should prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the different provisions (usually, this hierarchy is envisaged, ranging from the special to the general: order – order confirmation; framework agreement; general terms and conditions of purchase).
When is it important to conclude a purchase framework agreement?
It is beneficial to conclude this agreement when dealing with a mono-supplier or a supplier that would be very difficult to replace if it stopped selling products to the purchasing company.
The risks one aims to avoid or diminish are so-called stock-outs, i.e., supply interruptions due to the supplier’s lack of availability of products or because the products are available, but the parties cannot agree on the delivery time or sales price.
Another result that can be achieved is to bind a strategic supplier for a certain period by agreeing that it will reserve an agreed share of production for the buyer on predetermined terms and conditions and avoid competition with offers from third parties interested in the products for the duration of the agreement.
When is it helpful to conclude a sales framework agreement?
This agreement allows the seller/supplier to plan sales to a particular customer and thus to plan and organize its production and logistical capacity for the agreed period, avoiding extra costs or delays.
Planning sales also makes it possible to correctly manage financial obligations and cash flows with a medium-term vision, harmonizing commitments and investments with the sales to one’s customers.
What is the content of the supply framework agreement?
There is no standard model of this agreement, which originated from business practice to meet the requirements indicated above.
Generally, the agreement provides for a fixed period (e.g., 12 months) in which the parties undertake to conclude a series of purchases and sales of products, determining the price and terms of supply and the main covenants of future sales contracts.
The most important clauses are:
- the identification of products and technical specifications (often identified in an annex)
- the minimum/maximum volume of supplies
- the possible obligation to purchase/sell a minimum/maximum volume of products
- the schedule of supplies
- the delivery times
- the determination of the price and the conditions for its possible modification (see also the next paragraph)
- impediments to performance (Force Majeure)
- cases of Hardship
- penalties for delay or non-performance or for failure to achieve the agreed volumes
- the hierarchy between the framework agreement and the orders and any other contracts between the parties
- applicable law and dispute resolution (especially in international agreements)
How to handle price revision in a supply contract?
A crucial clause, especially in times of strong fluctuations in the prices of raw materials, transport, and energy, is the price revision clause.
In the absence of an agreement on this issue, the parties bear the risk of a price increase by undertaking to respect the conditions initially agreed upon; except in exceptional cases (where the fluctuation is strong, affects a short period, and is caused by unforeseeable events), it isn’t straightforward to invoke the supervening excessive onerousness, which allows renegotiating the price, or the contract to be terminated.
To avoid the uncertainty generated by price fluctuations, it is advisable to agree in the contract on the mechanisms for revising the price (e.g., automatic indexing following the quotation of raw materials). The so-called Hardship or Excessive Onerousness clause establishes what price fluctuation limits are accepted by the parties and what happens if the variations go beyond these limits, providing for the obligation to renegotiate the price or the termination of the contract if no agreement is reached within a certain period.
How to manage delivery terms in a supply agreement?
Another fundamental pact in a medium to long-term supply relationship concerns delivery terms. In this case, it is necessary to reconcile the purchaser’s interest in respecting the agreed dates with the supplier’s interest in avoiding claims for damages in the event of a delay, especially in the case of sales requiring intercontinental transport.
The first thing to be clarified in this regard concerns the nature of delivery deadlines: are they essential or indicative? In the first case, the party affected has the right to terminate (i.e., wind up) the agreement in the event of non-compliance with the term; in the second case, due diligence, information, and timely notification of delays may be required, whereas termination is not a remedy that may be automatically invoked in the event of a delay.
A useful instrument in this regard is the penalty clause: with this covenant, it is established that for each day/week/month of delay, a sum of money is due by way of damages in favor of the party harmed by the delay.
If quantified correctly and not excessively, the penalty is helpful for both parties because it makes it possible to predict the damages that may be claimed for the delay, quantifying them in a fair and determined sum. Consequently, the seller is not exposed to claims for damages related to factors beyond his control. At the same time, the buyer can easily calculate the compensation for the delay without the need for further proof.
The same mechanism, among other things, may be adopted to govern the buyer’s delay in accepting delivery of the goods.
Finally, it is a good idea to specify the limit of the penalty (e.g.,10 percent of the price of the goods) and a maximum period of grace for the delay, beyond which the party concerned is entitled to terminate the contract by retaining the penalty.
The Force Majeure clause in international sales contracts
A situation that is often confused with excessive onerousness, but is, in fact, quite different, is that of Force Majeure, i.e., the supervening impossibility of performance of the contractual obligation due to any event beyond the reasonable control of the party affected, which could not have been reasonably foreseen and the effects of which cannot be overcome by reasonable efforts.
The function of this clause is to set forth clearly when the parties consider that Force Majeure may be invoked, what specific events are included (e.g., a lock-down of the production plant by order of the authority), and what are the consequences for the parties’ obligations (e.g., suspension of the obligation for a certain period, as long as the cause of impossibility of performance lasts, after which the party affected by performance may declare its intention to dissolve the contract).
If the wording of this clause is general (as is often the case), the risk is that it will be of little use; it is also advisable to check that the regulation of force majeure complies with the law applicable to the contract (here an in-depth analysis indicating the regime provided for by 42 national laws).
Applicable law and dispute resolution clauses
Suppose the customer or supplier is based abroad. In that case, several significant differences must be borne in mind: the first is the agreement’s language, which must be intelligible to the foreign party, therefore usually in English or another language familiar to the parties, possibly also in two languages with parallel text.
The second issue concerns the applicable law, which should be expressly indicated in the agreement. This subject matter is vast, and here we can say that the decision on the applicable law must be made on a case-by-case basis, intentionally: in fact, it is not always convenient to recall the application of the law of one’s own country.
In most international sales contracts, the 1980 Vienna Convention on the International Sale of Goods («CISG») applies, a uniform law that is balanced, clear, and easy to understand. Therefore, it is not advisable to exclude it.
Finally, in a supply framework agreement with an international supplier, it is important to identify the method of dispute resolution: no solution fits all. Choosing a country’s jurisdiction is not always the right decision (indeed, it can often prove counterproductive).
Finalmente, tras más de 30 años de negociaciones, el mundo está ante el primer acuerdo comercial panafricano, que entró en vigor a principios de 2019: la Zona de Libre Comercio Continental Africana (African Continental Free Trade Area – AfCFTA).
África, con sus 55 países y unos 1.300 millones de habitantes, es el segundo continente más grande del mundo después de Asia. El potencial del continente es enorme: más del 50 % de la población africana tiene menos de 20 años y está creciendo al ritmo más rápido del mundo. Para 2050, se espera que uno de cada cuatro recién nacidos sea africano. Además, el continente es rico en suelo fértil y materias primas.
Para los inversores occidentales, África ha cobrado una importancia considerable en los últimos años. El auge del comercio internacional en este continente, entre otras cosas, es promovido por la iniciativa “Pacto con África” adoptada por los países del G20 en 2017, también conocida como el “Plan Marshall con África”. Su objetivo es ampliar la cooperación económica de África con los países del G20 reforzando la inversión privada.
Sin embargo, el comercio intraafricano actualmente ha estado estancado por causa de los aranceles intraafricanos, en parte todavía elevados, las barreras no arancelarias (non-tariff barriers – NTBs), la debilidad de las infraestructuras, la corrupción, la engorrosa burocracia, así como las normativas poco transparentes e incoherentes. Esto ha provocado que las exportaciones interregionales apenas pudieran desarrollarse y, más recientemente, solo representan el 17 % del comercio panafricano y sólo el 0,36 % del comercio mundial. Hace ya mucho tiempo que la Unión Africana (UA) incluyó en su agenda la creación de una zona comercial común.
¿Qué hay detrás del AfCFTA?
La creación de una zona de comercio panafricana estuvo precedida de décadas de negociaciones, que finalmente desembocaron en la entrada en vigor del AfCFTA el 30 de mayo de 2019.
El AfCFTA es una zona de libre comercio establecida por sus miembros, que -con la excepción de Eritrea- abarca todo el continente africano y es, por tanto, la mayor zona de libre comercio del mundo por número de Estados miembros después de la Organización Mundial del Comercio (OMC).
La estructuración detallada del mercado común fue objeto de varias negociaciones individuales, que se debatieron en las Fases I y II.
La Fase I comprende las negociaciones sobre tres protocolos y está casi concluida.
El Protocolo sobre el comercio de mercancías
Este protocolo prevé la eliminación del 90 % de todos los aranceles intraafricanos en todas las categorías de productos en un plazo de cinco años a partir de su entrada en vigor. De estos, hasta un 7 % de los productos pueden clasificarse como mercancías sensibles, que están sujetas a un periodo de eliminación arancelaria de diez años. Para los países menos adelantados (Least Developed Countries – LDCs), el periodo de preparación se amplía de cinco a diez años y para los productos sensibles de diez a trece años, siempre y cuando demuestren su necesidad. El 3 % restante de los aranceles queda totalmente exento del desarme arancelario.
Adicionalmente, debe tenerse en cuenta que el requisito previo para el desarme arancelario es la delimitación clara de las normas de origen. De lo contrario, las importaciones de terceros países podrían beneficiarse de las ventajas arancelarias negociadas. Ya se ha alcanzado un acuerdo sobre la mayoría de las normas de origen.
El Protocolo sobre el Comercio de Servicios
La Asamblea General de l’UA ha acordado hasta ahora cinco áreas prioritarias (transporte, comunicaciones, turismo, servicios financieros y empresariales) y directrices para los compromisos aplicables a las mismas. Hasta la fecha, 47 Estados miembros de l’UA han presentado sus ofertas de compromisos específicos y se ha completado la revisión de 28 de ellos. Además, siguen en curso las negociaciones, por ejemplo, sobre el reconocimiento de las cualificaciones profesionales.
El Protocolo sobre Solución de Diferencias
Con el Protocolo sobre normas y procedimientos por los que se rige la solución de diferencias, el AfCFTA crea un sistema de solución de diferencias inspirado en el Entendimiento sobre Solución de Diferencias de l’OMC. En virtud del mismo, el Órgano de Solución de Diferencias (Dispute Settlement Body – OSD) administra el Protocolo de Solución de Diferencias del AfCFTA y establece un Grupo Especial Adjudicador (Adjudicating Panel – Panel) y un Órgano de Apelación (Appellate Body – AB). El DSB está compuesto por un representante de cada Estado miembro e interviene en cuanto existen diferencias de opinión entre los Estados contratantes sobre la interpretación y/o aplicación del acuerdo en lo que respecta a sus derechos y obligaciones.
Para el resto de la Fase II están previstas negociaciones sobre política de inversión y competencia, cuestiones de propiedad intelectual, comercio en línea y mujeres y jóvenes en el comercio, cuyos resultados se reflejarán en posteriores protocolos.
La aplicación del AfCFTA
En principio, la aplicación del comercio en virtud de un acuerdo comercial sólo puede comenzar una vez que se haya aclarado definitivamente el marco jurídico. Sin embargo, los Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de l’UA acordaron en diciembre de 2020 que el comercio puede comenzar para los bienes cuyas negociaciones hayan finalizado. En virtud de este “acuerdo transitorio”, tras un aplazamiento relacionado con la pandemia, el primer acuerdo comercial AfCFTA de Ghana a Sudáfrica tuvo lugar el 4 de enero de 2021.
Elementos constitutivos del AfCFTA
Los 55 miembros de l’UA participaron en las negociaciones de la AfCFTA. De ellos, 47 pertenecen al menos a una – y algunos a más de una – Comunidades Económicas Regionales (Regional Economic Communities – RECs) reconocidas, que, según el preámbulo del acuerdo AfCFTA, deben seguir siendo los bloques de construcción del acuerdo comercial. Por tanto, fueron ellas las que actuaron como portavoces de sus respectivos miembros en las negociaciones del AfCFTA. El AfCFTA prevé que las RECs conserven sus instrumentos jurídicos, instituciones y mecanismos de resolución de conflictos.
Dentro de l’UA, hay ocho REC reconocidas, que se solapan en algunos países, y que son acuerdos comerciales preferenciales (Free Trade Agreements – FTAs) o uniones aduaneras.
En el marco del AfCFTA, las RECs tienen diversas responsabilidades. Se trata, en particular, de:
- coordinar las posiciones negociadoras y asistir a los Estados miembros en la aplicación del acuerdo;
- mediación orientada a la búsqueda de soluciones en caso de desacuerdo entre los Estados miembros;
- apoyar a los Estados miembros en la armonización de aranceles y otras normativas de protección fronteriza;
- promover el uso del procedimiento de notificación del AfCFTA para reducir las barreras no arancelarias.
Perspectivas de la AfCFTA
El AfCFTA tiene el potencial de facilitar la integración de África en la economía mundial y crea la posibilidad real de un reajuste de los modelos de integración y cooperación internacionales.
Un acuerdo comercial por sí solo no es garantía de éxito económico. Para que el acuerdo logre el avance previsto, los Estados miembros deben tener la voluntad política de aplicar las nuevas normas de forma coherente y crear la capacidad necesaria para ello. En particular, la eliminación a corto plazo de las barreras comerciales y la creación de una infraestructura física y digital sostenible serán probablemente cruciales.
Si está interesado en el AfCFTA, puede leer una versión ampliada de este artículo aquí.
Legalmondo Africa Desk
Ayudamos a las empresas a invertir y hacer negocios en África con nuestros expertos en Argelia, Túnez, Marruecos, Egipto, Ghana, Sudán, Libia, Senegal, Côte d’Ivoire, Camerún y Malawi.
También podemos ayudar a entidades extranjeras en países africanos en los que no estamos presentes directamente con una oficina a través de nuestra red de socios locales.
Cómo funciona
- Concertamos una reunión (en persona o en línea) con uno de nuestros expertos para entender las necesidades del cliente.
- Una vez que empezamos a trabajar juntos, atendemos al cliente con un abogado que se encarga de todas sus necesidades legales (casos individuales, o asistencia jurídica continua).
Póngase en contacto para saber más.
Summary
Political, environmental or health crises (like the Covid-19 outbreak and the attack of Ukraine by the Russian army) can cause an increase in the price of raw materials and components and generalized inflation. Both suppliers and distributors find themselves faced with problems related to the often sudden and very substantial increase in the price of their own supplies. French law lays down specific rules in that regard.
Two main situations can be distinguished: where the parties have just established a simple flow of orders and where the parties have concluded a framework agreement fixing firm prices for a fixed term.
Price increase in a business relationship
The situation is as follows: the parties have not concluded a framework agreement, each sales contract concluded (each order) is governed by the General T&Cs of the supplier; the latter has not undertaken to maintain the prices for a minimum period and applies the prices of the current tariff.
In principle, the supplier can modify its prices at any time by sending a new tariff. However, it must give written and reasonable notice in accordance with the provisions of Article L. 442-1.II of the Commercial Code, before the price increase comes into effect. Failure to respect sufficient notice, it could be accused of a sudden «partial» termination of commercial relations (and subject to damages).
A sudden termination following a price increase would be characterized when the following conditions are met:
- the commercial relationship must be established: broader concept than the simple contract, taking into account the duration but also the importance and the regularity of the exchanges between the parties;
- the price increase must be assimilated to a rupture: it is mainly the size of the price increase (+1%, 10% or 25%?) that will lead a judge to determine whether the increase constitutes a «partial» termination (in the event of a substantial modification of the relationship which is nevertheless maintained) or a total termination (if the increase is such that it involves a termination of the relationship) or if it does not constitute a termination (if the increase is minimal);
- the notice granted is insufficient by comparing the duration of the notice actually granted with that of the notice in accordance with Article L. 442-1.II, taking into account in particular the duration of the commercial relationship and the possible dependence of the victim of the termination with respect to the other party.
Article L. 442-1.II must be respected as soon as French law applies to the relation. In international business relations, to know how to deal with Article L.442-1.II and conflicts of laws and jurisdiction of competent courts, please see our previous article published on Legalmondo blog.
Price increase in a framework contract
If the parties have concluded a framework contract (such as supply, manufacturing, …) for several years and the supplier has committed to fixed prices, how, in this case, can it change these prices?
In addition to any indexation clause or renegotiation (hardship) clause which would be stipulated in the contract (and besides specific legal provisions applicable to special agreements as to their nature or economic sector), the supplier may seek to avail himself of the legal mechanism of «unforeseeability» provided for by article 1195 of the civil code.
Three prerequisites must be cumulatively met:
- an unforeseeable change in circumstances at the time of the conclusion of the contract (i.e.: the parties could not reasonably anticipate this upheaval);
- a performance of the contract that has become excessively onerous (i.e.: beyond the simple difficulty, the upheaval must cause a disproportionate imbalance);
- the absence of acceptance of these risks by the debtor of the obligation when concluding the contract.
The implementation of this mechanism must stick to the following steps:
- first, the party in difficulty must request the renegotiation of the contract from its co-contracting party;
- then, in the event of failure of the negotiation or refusal to negotiate by the other party, the parties can (i) agree together on the termination of the contract, on the date and under the conditions that they determine, or (ii) ask together the competent judge to adapt it;
- finally, in the absence of agreement between the parties on one of the two aforementioned options, within a reasonable time, the judge, seized by one of the parties, may revise the contract or terminate it, on the date and under the conditions that he will set.
The party wishing to implement this legal mechanism must also anticipate the following points:
- article 1195 of the Civil Code only applies to contracts concluded on or after October 1, 2016 (or renewed after this date). Judges do not have the power to adapt or rebalance contracts concluded before this date;
- this provision is not of public order. Therefore, the parties can exclude it or modify its conditions of application and/or implementation (the most common being the framework of the powers of the judge);
- during the renegotiation, the supplier must continue to sell at the initial price because, unlike force majeure, unforeseen circumstances do not lead to the suspension of compliance with the obligations.
Key takeaways:
- analyse carefully the framework of the commercial relationship before deciding to notify a price increase, in order to identify whether the prices are firm for a minimum period and the contractual levers for renegotiation;
- correctly anticipate the length of notice that must be given to the partner before the entry into force of the new pricing conditions, depending on the length of the relationship and the degree of dependence;
- document the causes of the price increase;
- check if and how the legal mechanism of unforeseeability has been amended or excluded by the framework contract or the General T&Cs;
- consider alternatives strategies, possibly based on stopping production/delivery justified by a force majeure event or on the significant imbalance of the contractual provisions.
Wine Market in Mexico 2020-2021
The wine market in Mexico has shown an annual growth of approximately 8% during the past 5 years.
Importations have increased during the past 10 years, increasing its value in 88%.
Mexico has the second highest consumption growth rate worldwide according to the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV).
Current Trends in Mexico
Mexican wines accounted for 29% of Mexico’s consumption, while the remaining 71% corresponds to imported wines.
Wine consumption is primarily concentrated in 3 cities, Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, with a potential increase in touristic locations.
Due to the health contingency generated as a result of the COVID19, on-line sales of the various supermarkets have increased in 300% during 2020.
Digitalization of processes represents a huge potential in terms of sales’ increase, and are expected to grow in a 40% yearly.
Consumers in Mexico are under 45 years old, having a pretty good balance in terms of gender (55% male and 45 female).
Types of wine consumed (71% red, 11% white, 9% sparkling, and 9% rose and others).
Comparison of wine consumption per capita
Following we share the following available information to illustrate differences between specific countries on current wine consumption per capita.
| Country | Consumption per capita |
| France | 49.5 lts |
| Italy | 43.0 lts |
| Austria | 29.4 lts |
| Spain | 27.8 lts |
| United States | 10.14 lts |
| China | 1.7 lts |
| Brazil | 1.6 lts |
| Mexico | 1.34 lts |
For more information you can visit our country guide on wine distribution in Mexico and watch the following video
Resumen
Al terminar los contratos de agencia y distribución la principal fuente de conflicto es la reclamación de una indemnización por clientela. La Ley española del Contrato de Agencia —al igual que la Directiva sobre Agentes comerciales— prevé que cuando se extingue el contrato, el agente tendrá derecho, si se dan determinadas condiciones, a una indemnización. En España, por analogía (aunque con salvedades y matices), esta indemnización se puede reclamar también en contratos de distribución.
Para que se reconozca esta indemnización es necesario que el agente (o el distribuidor: para más detalles, consulte este artículo) hayan aportado nuevos clientes o incrementado sensiblemente las operaciones con los preexistentes, que su actividad pueda seguir produciendo ventajas sustanciales al empresario y que resulte equitativo. Todo esto condiciona que se reconozca el derecho a la indemnización y su cuantía.
Estas expresiones (nuevos clientes, incremento sensible, pueda producir, ventajas sustanciales, equitativo) son difíciles de definir a priori, por lo que, para tener éxito, es recomendable que las reclamaciones ante los tribunales se apoyen, caso por caso, en informes de expertos, supervisados por un abogado.
Hay, al menos en España, una tendencia a reclamar directamente el máximo que prevé la norma (un año de remuneraciones calculada como media de los cinco anteriores) sin entrar en más análisis. Pero si se hace así, se corre el riesgo de que un juez rechace la petición por considerarla sin fundamento. Por lo tanto, y a partir de nuestra experiencia, me parece conveniente orientar sobre cómo fundamentar mejor la reclamación de esta indemnización y su cuantía.
Conviene que el agente/distribuidor, el perito y el abogado tengan en cuenta lo siguiente:
Comprobar cuál ha sido la aportación del agente
Si existían clientes antes de iniciarse el contrato y qué volumen de ventas se hacía con ellos. Para reconocer esta indemnización es necesario que el agente haya incrementado el número de clientes o las operaciones con los preexistentes.
Analizar la importancia de esos clientes a la hora de seguir aportando ventajas al empresario
Su recurrencia, su fidelidad (al empresario y no al agente), la tasa de migración (cuántos seguirán con el empresario al concluir el contrato o con el agente). En efecto, Será difícil hablar de “clientela” si solo ha habido clientes esporádicos, ocasionales, no recurrentes (o poco) o que seguirán permaneciendo fieles al agente y no al empresario.
Cómo se queda el agente al terminar el contrato
¿Podrá hacer competencia al empresario o hay restricciones en el contrato? Si el agente puede seguir atendiendo a los mismos clientes, pero para un empresario diferente, la indemnización se podría discutir bastante.
¿Es equitativa la indemnización?
Examinar cómo ha actuado el agente en el pasado: si ha cumplido sus obligaciones, su trabajo a la hora de introducir los productos o abrir el mercado, la posible evolución de tales productos o servicios en el futuro, etc.
¿Perderá comisiones el agente?
Aquí hay que examinar si tenía exclusividad; su mayor o menor facilidad para hacerse con un nuevo contrato (p.ej. por edad, crisis económica, el tipo de productos, etc.) o con una nueva fuente de ingresos, la evolución de las ventas durante los últimos años (las consideradas para la indemnización), etc.
Es necesario también calcular el máximo legal que no podrá superarse
La media anual de lo percibido durante el período del contrato (o de 5 años si duró más). Esto incluirá no solo las comisiones, sino cualquier cantidad fija, bonificaciones, premios, etc. o los márgenes en caso los distribuidores.
Y, por último, conviene incluir en el informe del experto todos los documentos analizados
Si no se hace así y solo se mencionan, podría dar lugar a que no se tengan en cuenta por un juez.
Consulte la Guía Práctica sobre Contratos de Agencia Internacional
Para leer más sobre las principales características de un contrato de agencia en España, consulte nuestra Guía.
Resale prices maintenance on the internet is unlawful while ban on resale on third-party platforms seems to be a new lawful option
In a nutshell
On December 3, 2020 the French Competition Authority (the FCA) :
- reiterated clearly the illegality of behavior aimed at imposing resale prices, especially in e-commerce and then condemned Dammann Frères, a French manufacturer of premium teas, to a € 226,000 fine for imposing minimum online resale prices maintenance on its distributors
- extended the right of ban on resale on third-party platforms from selective distribution of luxury products to quite common commercial relations, and then rejected the alleged illegality of this ban.
Between “recommended” and “imposed” resale prices: a dangerous game to play
Article L 442-6 of French Commercial Code prohibits «imposing, directly or indirectly, a minimum character at the resale price of a good, at the price of a service or at a commercial margin”. The FCA has ruled that, under the pretext of communicating recommended prices to its distributors, Dammann Frères has in fact imposed resale prices on them, failure to comply with these prices being punishable by retaliations (removal or reduction of the amount of discounts granted to them, delay in deliveries, removal of their contact details from the list of distributors presented on its website, disruption of supply, or even termination of commercial relations).
The supplier justified – vainly – this practice by its will to preserve the image and the positioning of its products but above all to avoid excessive price differences between resales by distributors on the internet and those carried out by network stores (where dealers had more latitude in setting prices).
The restriction of competition resulting from resale price maintenance can be obvious when contractual stipulations directly fix the price; but it can be deduced from a set of indices which is characterized according to a method strictly applied by the FCA :
- the supplier communicates its (recommended) resale prices to distributors,
- the latter apply them significantly and,
- a “price policing” system is put in place to prevent the price agreement from being questioned by deviant distributors. This mechanism results in price monitoring by the supplier (or even by other distributors, etc.),
- this leads to pressure, or even retaliation, to force distributors to align their prices upwards, such as delivery delays, supply disruptions, removal of discounts, etc.
There is a fine line between a price surveillance mechanism and a price constraint mechanism. This legal insecurity has been criticized and the European Commission could provide, on the occasion of the upcoming reform of the European block exemption regulation on vertical restraints, additional advice on the circumstances in which recommended resale prices should be qualified as imposed resale prices. The reform expected in 2022 could even go further by highlighting the pro-competitive effects of resale price maintenance.
Ban on resale on third-party platforms: a serious option to consider
With regard to the ban on the resale of its products on third-party platforms, openly imposed by Dammann Frères, the FCA took a rather liberal and innovative approach by applying the rules of the Coty case law (ruling of 6 12 2017, Coty Germany GmbH, C 230/16) to decide ultimately that there is no need to prosecute and therefore to fine. If this approach is confirmed later on by French courts, it will have a considerable impact on suppliers ‘policy who seek to control and restrict the terms of resale of their products on third-party platforms such as Amazon or e-Bay.
In this case, the FCA noted that the tea manufacturer’s market share was less than 30% and that this restriction did not constitute a hardcore restriction. Indeed, the FCA noted that this practice (i) did not prohibit distributors from selling products online nor from marketing themselves through third party websites (advertising and use of search engines) and (ii) did not constitute a restriction on the number of distributors, as the prosecution file did not evidence the number of customers of these platforms amongst the group of online buyers.
The FCA’s decision is therefore extends the Coty case law according to which the supplier of a selective distribution network for luxury products can prohibit the resale of its products on third-party platforms in order to preserve the image of its products (see our comments Here).
The FCA had already extended the Coty case law to technical products in a decision of 24 October 2018 (n ° 18-D-23), concerning the practices of the company Stihl, leader in mechanized garden equipment (mainly confirmed on appeal, Paris court of appeal 17 10 19), where the FCA, in a premonitory manner, stated: “it is important to specify that the analysis carried out by the Court of justice in the Coty ruling for the online marketing of luxury products seems likely to be extended to other types of products ”(see our comments Here).
The FCA is now going even further because, even though Dammann Frères teas are “high-end” positioned, they are neither luxury products nor even distributed through a selective distribution network.
Key takeaway
As part of its relations with its distributors, the supplier must ensure:
- not to stipulate any express minimum resale price clause;
- not to implement a system, nor tolerate practices, of commercial retaliation against distributors deviating from the minimum «recommended» prices (or even threaten them to do so);
- not to prohibit them from selling the products online or from advertising online;
- carefully examine the possibility of prohibiting them from reselling its products on third-party platforms.









