-
Espagne
Goodwill indemnity in Spain: limits of a waiver
15 novembre 2026
- Distribution
- Litiges
In Spain, a waiver of goodwill indemnity in a distribution agreement does not always protect the manufacturer. The Barcelona Provincial Court of Appeal ordered a manufacturer to pay its distributor more than EUR 100,000 in goodwill indemnity and damages for insufficient notice, despite the written waiver, because it held that the agreement had expired and that good faith limited the waiver’s effect. To avoid the same risk, the manufacturer should renew the agreement in writing before it expires or expressly provide that waivers remain effective, specify which customer base the waiver covers and give notice proportionate to the duration of the relationship.
Summary
- The distributor’s case and the manufacturer’s liability
- What the Court of Appeal decided on the waiver
- Why the waiver was not applied
- A valid waiver with limits: distribution and agency
- Whether the waiver should have fallen away with the agreement
- What manufacturers distributing in Spain should do
Goodwill indemnity in Spain: the distributor’s case
For more than twenty years, the manufacturer and distributor worked together without a written agreement. In 2018, they signed a two-year contract. The distributor agreed to waive both goodwill indemnity and damages arising from termination.
The agreement expired in December 2020. Neither party renewed it, but they continued doing business together.
Months later, the manufacturer decided to end the relationship. It gave less than two months’ notice and alleged breaches by the distributor that it was unable to prove.
Waiver of goodwill indemnity: what the Court of Appeal decided
In a distribution relationship, the distributor can waive goodwill indemnity. In an agency relationship, an advance waiver is not permitted. In this case, however, the Court of Appeal held that the waiver no longer applied because the agreement had expired and the parties had continued trading without renewing it. The court also considered that good faith could limit the waiver’s effect, given the length of the relationship and its termination without good cause.
The argument based on expiry is debatable: a clause intended to govern the end of an agreement should not lose its effect simply because that agreement ends. To avoid this uncertainty, parties that continue trading after expiry should renew the agreement in writing or expressly provide that waivers remain effective.
Why was the goodwill indemnity waiver not applied?
The Court of Appeal relied on two grounds.
The first was the expiry of the agreement. Since the parties had continued trading without signing a new document, the court held that the waiver was no longer effective when the manufacturer ended the relationship.
The second was good faith. Even if the waiver still applied, the court considered that it could not take full effect in those circumstances: more than twenty-five years of collaboration, a customer base developed by the distributor and termination without good cause.
Goodwill indemnity waiver: valid, but with limits
The judgment is surprising because a distributor can, in principle, waive this indemnity. To understand why, it helps to distinguish distribution from agency.
In agency relationships, the law protects the agent against an advance waiver. This follows from Article 3 of Spain’s Commercial Agency Act, Law 12/1992, read together with the goodwill indemnity provisions in Article 28.
In distribution relationships, the Spanish Supreme Court applies Article 28 by analogy where its requirements are met (judgment 944/2023 of 13 June). But this does not prevent a manufacturer and distributor from agreeing to exclude all compensation if either party terminates the agreement on notice. The Supreme Court confirmed this in its judgments of 4 December 2007, 15 January 2008, sitting in plenary session, and 25 April 2011.
The distinction lies in how the relationship ends. That case law concerns ordinary termination, whether on notice or on expiry of the agreed term. A waiver offers less certainty where the manufacturer ends the relationship without good cause and gives insufficient notice, as happened here.
Should the waiver have fallen away with the agreement?
Of the Court of Appeal’s two grounds, the first is the more debatable: that the waiver ceased to apply because the agreement had expired.
The Spanish Supreme Court has enforced exclusion clauses precisely after an agreement has expired. It did so in its judgment of 23 December 2008. In that case, a dealer’s agreement ended when its extension expired. The court refused goodwill compensation because the agreement itself excluded any claim arising from its termination.
The point is straightforward: if a clause is agreed to govern what happens when an agreement ends, it is difficult to argue that it loses its effect merely because the agreement ends.
There is a difference here: the parties continued trading after expiry and, according to the Court of Appeal, did so on the terms that had traditionally governed their relationship. But continuing to trade does not, by itself, show that they intended to set aside a waiver relating to the customer base developed up to that point.
There is an agency case that might appear to point the other way. The Supreme Court has prevented parties from dividing the indemnity into separate periods through successive declarations that there was “nothing further to claim” (judgment of 27 June 2013). Its reason, however, was the mandatory protection afforded by Article 28 of the Spanish Commercial Agency Act, which the parties cannot exclude. That restriction does not apply to distribution.
Even if the waiver remained effective, there would still be the question of notice. Damages for failing to give sufficient notice address a different loss. They compensate the distributor for not having had a reasonable period to reorganise its business and would therefore not necessarily be covered by that waiver.
What should manufacturers distributing in Spain do?
Businesses may continue trading as usual and overlook the fact that their agreement has expired. This judgment illustrates the risk: when the time comes to end the relationship, the manufacturer may discover that the protections it relied on are no longer effective.
The agreement should be renewed in writing before it expires. If the parties have already continued trading without renewal, they should document which terms still apply and expressly provide that waivers remain effective both after expiry and while the relationship continues without a new document.
It is also important to specify which customer base the waiver covers. If it is intended to include the customer base already built up, this should be stated expressly, with a reference date, a defined territory and confirmation that the waiver is final.
Finally, goodwill indemnity, damages for insufficient notice and other damages should be addressed separately. When ending the relationship, the manufacturer should give notice proportionate to its duration.
Frequently asked questions on goodwill indemnity in Spain
Is a waiver of goodwill indemnity valid in a distribution agreement in Spain?
In principle, yes: in distribution the distributor can waive the indemnity, whereas in agency the law protects the agent against an advance waiver (Article 3 of Spain’s Commercial Agency Act, Law 12/1992). A waiver offers less certainty, however, where the manufacturer ends the relationship without good cause and gives insufficient notice.
What happens to the waiver if the agreement expires and the parties keep trading?
The risk is that it will not be applied. In the case decided by the Barcelona Provincial Court of Appeal, the waiver was held to be no longer effective because the agreement had expired and the parties had continued trading without renewing it. The argument is debatable, but to avoid uncertainty the agreement should be renewed in writing or should expressly provide that waivers remain effective.
Can good faith limit a waiver of goodwill indemnity?
According to the court, in that case it could: after more than twenty-five years of collaboration, with a customer base developed by the distributor and termination without good cause, the waiver could not take full effect.
Does the waiver also cover damages for insufficient notice?
Not necessarily. Damages for failing to give sufficient notice address a different loss, because they compensate the distributor for not having had a reasonable period to reorganise its business.
How should the waiver be worded to cover the customer base already built up?
It must say so expressly: the waiver should state a reference date, a defined territory and that the waiver is final.
How much notice must the manufacturer give?
The article does not give a number of days: it says that notice must be proportionate to the duration of the relationship. In the case examined, the manufacturer gave less than two months’ notice after more than twenty-five years of collaboration.










