How can the buyer reduce clawback risks?
If the parties decide not to frame the transaction within a pre-insolvency or insolvency procedure under the CCII, it is highly recommended that the buyer conducts careful review and evaluation of the seller’s situation and of the distressed asset.
As a first step, a thorough due diligence should be carried out in order to understand whether the seller is currently in a state of crisis or insolvency, which could therefore significantly increase the risk of the transaction: an accounting, tax, and legal analysis has to be carried out to verify the reliability of the information provided by the seller, and to ascertain the exact amount of debts and the value of the corporate assets.
From a more purely economic point of view, on the other hand, it is appropriate to conduct a business audit through which the main elements that characterize the business (such as positioning, level of technology, quality of management, state of property and facilities, etc.) should be examined.
In addition to that, it would be careful to commission an appraisal which proves that the purchase price of the asset is equal to – or not excessively lower than – the market value, to prevent possible legal risks related to clawback actions and patrimonial bankruptcy offences.
Once these activities are completed, the buyer is able to decide whether to proceed with the transaction, having obtained at this point all the necessary information to properly conduct a risk assessment from both a legal and economic perspective.
In any case, in this scenario, the buyer will remain exposed to possible legal risks, especially regarding clawback actions (should the requirements be met).
How can the buyer limit liability for business debts and taxes?
In the event of a sale of the business or business unit, the buyer may exclude or limit its liability:
for the debts of the business (Article 2560 of the Civil Code):
- by an explicit waiver to such liability by each creditor, prior to the closing of the sale, or;
- by assuming the debts and reducing the price of the same amount;
for the tax liabilities of the business (Article 14 of the Decree n. 472 of 1997), the buyer may ask the Revenue Agency (‘Agenzia delle Entrate’) for a tax certificate regarding the business’ tax liabilities. The buyer remains liable only for the liabilities, if any, included in such certificate, and the buyer is not liable if the certificate is not issued within 40 days of request.
How can the buyer address employee liabilities?
In the event of a sale of the business or business unit, if the buyer:
• do not want to retain all employees; and/or
• wants to limit its liability for debts and claims vis à vis any employee;
it may enter into an agreement with the relevant employees.
How can the buyer address liability under D.Lgs. 231/2001?
Liability pursuant to Article 33 of Legislative Decree No. 231/2001 can be excluded by conducting a targeted due diligence on the seller to verify whether any administrative fine has been imposed under the Legislative Decree n. 231/2001, and whether an investigation is ongoing with regard to a relevant offence. If neither of these circumstances is found, the purchaser is not liable.